Showing posts with label lockdown protests. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lockdown protests. Show all posts

Saturday, January 17, 2026

Canadian gov't loses Emergencies Act appeal

A Federal Appeals Court has ruled that the Canadian government's use of the Emergencies Act to terminate the 2022 Freedom Convoy protests was unreasonable and violated Charter rights. 

Maksim Sokolov  Freedom Convoy protesters, Ottawa, Feb. 12, 2022. CC BY-SAWikimedia Commons.

January 16, 2026 - 'The Liberal government unreasonably invoked the Emergencies Act to clear the convoy protests that gridlocked the capital city and border points nearly four years ago,' the Federal Court of Appeal ruled on Friday.

"The court dismissed the government's appeal of a 2024 ruling which deemed former prime minister Justin Trudeau's decision to use the legislation [was] unlawful and infringed on protesters' Charter rights.... The Federal Court was initially asked to review the government's deeply divisive proclamation of a public order emergency by the Canadian Civil Liberties Association (CCLA), the Canadian Constitution Foundation and other groups. In that 2024 decision, Federal Court Justice Richard Mosley, since retired, said the government's decision lacked justification, transparency and intelligibility.

"The government appealed. During a hearing last February, its lawyers argued the court downplayed violence with 'hindsight bias on full display.' The government has long argued the protests posed a security threat and the measures it took under the Emergencies Act were targeted, proportional and temporary. 

"But the appeal court's decision agreed with Mosley's finding that cabinet did not have reasonable grounds to believe that a threat to national security existed and fell short of the legal threshold needed to invoke the act."

Read more: https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/convoy-protest-emergencies-act-appeal-9.7046769

Friday, July 25, 2025

Double standard in Lich-Barber prosecution

"The selective prosecution (or non-prosecution) of offences committed by protesters, based on the protesters’ political views rather than on their behaviour, is a serious affront to the rule of law."

The Glaring Double Standard in the Prosecution of Lich and Barber | Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms | John Carpay:

July 24, 2025 - "If Chris Barber and Tamara Lich had organized a series of massive rallies in Ottawa to protest the federal government’s failure to control the earth’s climate, would they have been criminally charged with mischief and held responsible for clogging up Ottawa’s downtown core?... If the rude anti-Trudeau flags displayed by some truckers had instead been rainbow flags, or Hamas flags, would the federal government have declared a national emergency, and used violence against peaceful protesters? And would Crown prosecutors now be asking for an eight-year jail sentence for Barber and seven for Lich? 

"Sadly, these are questions that must be asked in light of what appears to be a glaring double standard that sees crimes in Canada being prosecuted — or ignored — depending on the politics of the protesters.

"In July 2021, 'protesters' tore down and damaged a large statue of Queen Victoria on the [Manitoba] Legislature grounds, in broad daylight, with police watching.... In February 2022, Manitoba Justice announced that, while property destruction was a crime and not a valid exercise of freedom of expression, none of the criminals would be prosecuted!... In March 2020, protesters blockaded railroads across Canada in the name of stopping oil and gas development.... Prime Minister Trudeau offered to meet with them, and police did little.... Less than two years later, thousands of Canadians, including many truckers, assembled peacefully in Ottawa to protest vaccine mandates. The prime minister refused to meet with them, declared a 'national emergency,' and then the protesters were met by the force of armed police and had their bank accounts frozen.

"On May 11, 2020, lone protester Cody Haller was arrested, dragged out of the Alberta legislature grounds, and given a $1,200 dollar ticket. The 'rule of law' was apparently very important when people protested against the violation of their Charter freedoms: complete and total obedience to health orders was expected.... A few weeks later, neither police nor Crown prosecutors objected to anti-racism protests across Canada that were clearly in violation of public health orders. In Regina, the chief of police spoke at one of these clearly illegal rallies.... 

"The selective prosecution (or non-prosecution) of offences committed by protesters, based on the protesters’ political views rather than on their behaviour, is a serious affront to the rule of law.


Chris Barber and Tamara Lich. CBC photos.

"Crown prosecutors in Ottawa are now seeking jail sentences for Barber and Lich that are too rarely imposed on people convicted of serious crimes. The Crown also seeks to confiscate Barber’s truck, affectionately known as Big Red, even though Barber had followed instructions from Ottawa police about where to park Big Red, and later moved Big Red after police requested him to do so. The Crown does not dispute that the Freedom Convoy, in which thousands of people participated over the course of three weeks, was devoid of the violence, vandalism, arson, threats, and other criminal conduct that frequently characterize other protests.... 

"When convicting Lich and Barber of criminal mischief, the judge noted that 'Ms. Lich and Mr. Barber consistently said this was to be a peaceful protest. There are no messages, Tik Tok or otherwise, where they used violence or threats of same. They did not incite or aid supporters in engaging in intimidating, aggressive or threatening behaviors by their mischief or blocking roads. They were not trying to intimidate the downtown residents....There are no words spoken where they suggested to make it difficult for police to do their lawful duties. The actions of the Accused on their respective arrests were consistent with what they told their followers; their actions led by example'....

"Lich has already spent 49 days in jail. Both Lich and Barber have been subjected to more than three years of criminal proceedings, while Crown prosecutors in Ontario claim that they lack adequate resources to prosecute murders and other serious crimes.

"The double standard in law enforcement in Canada is glaring. If the judge imposes any jail time on Lich, Barber, or both, it will bring the administration of justice into grave disrepute in the minds of millions of Canadians, and further tear our social fabric."

Read more: https://www.jccf.ca/epoch-times-the-glaring-double-standard-in-the-prosecution-of-lich-and-barber/ 
– or Read this column in Epoch Times

A personal message from John Carpay as we await Chris Barber’s sentencing | Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms | July 23, 2025: 

Wednesday, June 4, 2025

Hillier ruling strengthens Charter right of assembly

In this year's case of Hillier v. Ontario, for the first time ever, a Canadian court has invoked the Charter right of peaceful assembly to overturn a law as unconstitutional.   


Hillier at 2021 anti-lockdown protest, Niagara Falls, Ont, Photo: Beth Baisch, Dreamstime

Ontario court ruling in Hillier case a positive sign for Charter freedoms | Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms | John Carpay:

April 10, 2025 - "Since lockdowns were imposed in March 2020, governments across Canada have admitted in numerous court challenges that provincial and federal health orders did violate one or more of the Charter freedoms of conscience, religion, expression, peaceful assembly, association, and mobility. In like manner, governments have admitted that vaccine mandates violated the Charter right to bodily autonomy. Canadian courts have consistently upheld these Charter violations as being reasonable and justified in a free and democratic society — until the Ontario Court of Appeal delivered its judgment in Hillier v. Ontario on April 7.

"Randy Hillier, a former Member of Ontario’s Provincial Parliament, challenged Ontario’s total and absolute ban on all outdoor protests, which the government imposed on citizens in April and May of 2021. While up to 10 people could gather for a wedding or funeral, or for a religious service or ceremony, it was illegal for two people to meet outdoors for a peaceful protest!

"Mr. Hillier faced charges and fines up to $100,000 for organizing peaceful political protests in Kemptville and Cornwall, and for attending protests in Smiths Falls, Belleville, Peterborough, Stratford, Kitchener, and Chatham throughout April and May 2021. His defence to these charges was that Ontario unjustifiably restricted his Charter freedom of peaceful assembly. In court, Ontario presented no evidence that its total ban on outdoor protests, including those in which Mr. Hillier participated, would reduce the spread of Covid.

"Overturning the November 2023 lower court ruling, Court of Appeal Justices Lauwers, Zarnett, and Pomerance ruled unanimously that Ontario’s absolute ban on peaceful assembly in 2021, particularly outdoor political protests, was an unjustified violation of the freedom of peaceful assembly as protected by Section 2(c) of the Charter.... The court declared that it could not countenance 'an outcome in which the state eliminates the free exercise of a fundamental freedom, without giving that elimination any actual thought'.... While stating that 'the pandemic posed significant challenges for Ontario,' the court declared that 'the Constitution does not fade from view in times of crisis.' 

"For the first time in Canadian judicial history, an appellate court has outlined the nature, purpose, and benefits of the Charter section 2(c) freedom of peaceful assembly, declaring it 'elemental' and 'integral to a functioning democracy.' Previously, peaceful assembly has been ignored and subsumed into the other Charter section 2 freedoms.... Peaceful assembly differs from the other fundamental freedoms because 'a demonstration is an act of solidarity, a coming together of similarly minded individuals,' who can 'make visible the extent and depth of support for a position,' the ruling said.

"The freedom of peaceful assembly protects the ability of citizens to get the community to pay attention to their message of protest or dissent, and entice others to become involved in redressing grievances. The court noted that 'outdoor protests are especially effective at amplifying minority voices and expressing political dissent.' Ontario’s total ban on peaceful protests denied citizens of their 'opportunity to influence public policy by this time-honoured method.' Significantly, the court ruled that social media and virtual gatherings ... cannot replace the 'traditional means of participating in public assemblies'..... 

"Governments across Canada have been put on notice that they cannot ban peaceful political gatherings. Freedom-loving Canadians can be encouraged that the Ontario Court of Appeal has elevated a previously 'forgotten freedom' to overturn a Covid-era ban on the exercise of that same Charter freedom. Could protection of Charter freedoms in Canada be making a comeback?"

Read more: https://www.jccf.ca/ontario-court-ruling-in-hillier-case-a-positive-sign-for-charter-freedoms/

The bridge to Freedom is never too far. Hillier Wins-Government loses! |  Randy Hillier | April 7, 2025:

Tuesday, September 5, 2023

Trial of Tamara Lich & Chris Barber begins today

More than 18 months after being charged, Freedom Convoy organizers Tamara Lich and Chris Barber get their scheduled four weeks in court.

Tamara Lich trial starting Tuesday | Western Standard | Lee Harding:

September 4, 2023 - "Tamara Lich is going to trial and those crowdfunding her defence say they will live tweet all the proceedings. The four-week trial for the Freedom Convoy leader starts Sept. 5.  The Democracy Fund (TDF) is crowdfunding Lich’s legal defence and promises TDF lawyers will provide daily real-time insights and updates directly from the courtroom at Twitter.com/TDF_Can. Through the live posts, the organization aims 'to foster transparency, engagement, and understanding surrounding the legal proceedings' which it calls 'a significant moment in Canada's legal and social landscape.' Lich’s legal team is led by Lawrence Greenspon, a senior criminal lawyer in Ottawa....

"'Tamara's prosecution shows how a prominent political dissident is treated by our justice system," said Alan Honner, TDF's director of litigation. 'The trucker convoy exposed the government's willingness to invoke extraordinary powers to suppress a nationwide protest that was remarkably peaceful,' added Honner. 'Tamara has become the face of that protest, so there is a lot at stake in the outcome of her trial.'

"On July 28, TDF announced its lawyers would represent 12 clients charged with more than 24 offences arising from the Freedom Convoy in Ottawa and Windsor. These clients include a decorated Canadian military veteran, an indigenous single father and a law school grad. The charges range from mischief, breach of a court order and breach of bail conditions to obstruction of a police officer. In each of these cases, the Crown is seeking up to three months in prison. TDF pledged to 'vigorously advance all defences available to our clients.'

"Most trials for TDF clients are expected to take between two to five days each, yet TDF expects back-to-back trials from Dec 2023 to Feb 2024."

Read more: https://www.westernstandard.news/news/tamara-lich-trial-starting-tuesday/article_4645a616-4901-11ee-8aa8-87451fdb9b2e.html

Freedom Convoy Trial Inbound - Chris Barber & Tamara Lich Gear Up for Legal Fight with The Feds | Clyde Do Something | August 1, 2023:

‘Freedom Convoy’ duo faces trial in Ottawa. Here’s what the charges mean | Global News | David Baxter, with files from The Canadian Press and Rachel Gilmore:  

September 5, 2023 - "Tamara Lich and Chris Barber are both accused of mischief, obstructing police, counselling others to commit mischief, and intimidation. As the trial gets underway and is expected to last 16 days, Global News breaks down what these charges mean.

"Under the Criminal Code, mischief has a broad definition. It’s characterized as the willful destruction of property, making it dangerous or useless to others and/or obstructing, interrupting or interfering with the lawful enjoyment of property of others.... Michael Spratt, an Ottawa-based defence lawyer ... Spratt says that it is not uncommon to see mischief charges in a large protest or demonstration that disrupts a community.... Spratt says that neither Lich nor Barber necessarily had to be among the people actively honking horns, for instance.... As leadership figures in the convoy, there is a possibility they can be held responsible for the actions of others. This goes along with the counselling to commit mischief charge.... The central mischief charges carry a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison if convicted, but Spratt sees that as highly unlikely....

"With respect to the charge of intimidation, Spratt pointed to the many stories of downtown Ottawa residents not feeling safe in their community while the convoy was occupying the city for those three weeks in February 2021....

"On the final charge — obstructing police — Spratt says Lich and Barber may still be found liable for things they didn’t do themselves due to their perceived leadership positions.... '“If the Crown is able to prove with evidence in court that they took steps to encourage other people to continue lawless behaviour or obstruct police or intimidate others through actions like telling people to hold the line or to ignore dispersal orders, it’s those types of, controlling actions that can lead them to be liable and to be convicted,' he said.

"Lich famously said 'hold the line' in a video of her arrest when police moved in to begin breaking up the protest. 'Hold the line' was used as a rallying cry of sorts throughout the protest by many people involved. It is also the title of Lich’s memoir." 

Read more: https://globalnews.ca/news/9937749/freedom-convoy-tamara-lich-chris-barber-charges/

Friday, July 14, 2023

Covid charges dropped against Sloan and Hillier

Charges against former MP Derek Sloan and former Ontario MPP Randy Hillier for attending a banned "No More Lockdowns" 2021 protest in Stratford, Ontario, have been dropped by the Crown. 

Charges dropped against former MP Derek Sloan and MPP Randy Hillier | Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms:

July 12, 2023 - "The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms is pleased to announce that charges against Mr. Derek Sloan and Mr. Randy Hillier were dropped on Thursday, June 29, 2023.  Both men allegedly attended a rally against Covid-19 lockdown measures in April 2021.


Randy Hillier, 2018. Photo by Dave Li.

"On April 8, 2021, the Ontario government declared a state of emergency over increasing cases of Covid-19. The government then implemented its most draconian measures yet by instituting an outdoor gathering ban which effectively made peaceful political protest illegal in Ontario. Mr. Sloan was a former MP, and Mr. Hillier was a sitting MPP at the time. Both believed that these lockdowns were harmful and attended these gatherings to protest the measures.  

"On April 25, 2021, there was a 'No More Lockdowns' protest in Stratford, which the 2 men attended. At the time, the Ontario government’s regulations stated that zero persons were allowed to gather outdoors.... The Ontario government did this despite the fact most experts agree that spread of respiratory viruses at short duration, outdoor events are extremely limited. Mr. Sloan and Mr. Hillier each faced a maximum fine of $100,000 for attending this protest. 

"The prosecutor agreed to drop the charges in exchange for a modest charitable donation or volunteer work.  Mr. Sloan made the charitable donation and Mr. Hillier volunteered at a food bank in Lanark County. 


Derek Sloan, 2020. Photo by Danman 2010.
“'The Ontario government’s lockdowns, which effectively banned any political protesting whatsoever, were a grave threat to our freedom in Canada. Restrictions may be over for now, but there was no indication how long they would last at the time. 2 weeks became 2 months which became almost 2 years of failed COVID policies.', says Mr. Sloan. 'I am proud to have stood against this tyranny with many other brave Canadians. 

"'The Stratford prosecutor made the right choice, and it is now up to other prosecutors in other districts to drop these meaningless charges. One day, history, and the courts, will concur that these lockdowns were unwarranted and a serious and unnecessary interference with Canadian’s basic freedoms,' he continued. 

"Both Mr. Hillier and Mr. Sloan have similar outstanding charges in Ontario. Mr. Hillier has launched a Charter challenge against the lockdowns that banned all outdoor protests, and will argue that they were an unjustifiable infringement of his rights. The hearing is set for July 27-28, 2023."

Read more: https://www.jccf.ca/charges-dropped-against-former-mp-derek-sloan-and-mpp-randy-hillier/ 

Thursday, December 15, 2022

Ontario pastor fined for 2021 lockdown protest

Aylmer pastor fined $5K after attending anti-lockdown London rally | London Free Press:

December 1, 2022 - "The leader of an Aylmer church that became an anti-lockdown flashpoint at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic has been fined $5,000 for participating in a downtown London rally last winter. 

"Church of God pastor Henry Hildebrandt was convicted under the Reopening Ontario Act, the law to enforce public-health measures to combat the spread of COVID-19, for attending the so-called World Wide Rally for Freedom on Jan. 22 at Victoria Park, municipal officials said on Thursday. Hildebrandt was fined $5,000 and ordered to pay court costs....

"The London rally was part of a movement in opposition to public-health measures such as limits on public gatherings, mandatory masking and the closure of businesses and schools....  Hildebrandt became a leading figure in the movement opposed to the government’s handling of the pandemic. He continued to hold both drive-in and indoor services at his Aylmer church, drawing attention from police and criticism from counter-protesters who held demonstrations outside its grounds.

"The defiant pastor racked up court fines and tickets since the beginning of the pandemic. He was charged along with then-MPPs Randy Hillier and Derek Sloan for attending a Norfolk County rally in June 2021, but the charges against the trio were dropped in September, according the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (JCCF), a legal advocacy group hired to represent the men.

"The JCCF, a charity dedicated to fighting for constitutional freedoms, has taken on many cases of individuals charges under the Reopening Ontario Act. The legal group scored a recent victory when charges against a Goderich family that was fined for holding a birthday party were dropped on Nov. 2. The family had gathered to celebrate a birthday on April 23, 2021, amid a stay-at-home order that prohibited residents from leaving their homes except for approved reasons.... A lawyer for the Justice Centre worked out a deal with the Crown to drop the charges in exchange for the family agreeing to make a 'modest' charitable donation, the centre said.

“'While we are pleased that the charges have been dropped, it is concerning that these charges were laid at all,' Justice Centre lawyer Chris Naimi said in a statement issued Wednesday. 'The right to peaceful assembly is an enshrined constitutional right, whether it is a public political demonstration or an intimate family gathering.'"

Read more: https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/controversial-pastor-fined-5k-after-attending-anti-lockdown-london-rally

Who is Pastor Henry Hildebrand?, The Democracy Fund, Dec. 14, 2021:

Sunday, December 4, 2022

Biden's double standard on Covid protests

President Biden has urged the Chinese government to respect the rights of anti-lockdown protesters. He actively encouraged the Canadian government to end the Freedom Convoy protests.

Biden's Support for COVID Protests Hinges on What Country They're in | Reason - Christian Britschgi:

November 29, 2022 - "The White House has been quick to support the rights of Chinese demonstrators taking to the streets in opposition to the country's 'Zero COVID' policy and the seemingly endless lockdowns needed to enforce it. Recent revelations show that closer to home, the administration actively encouraged a civil liberties-violating crackdown on Canadian protests against vaccine mandates.

"'We think it's going to be very difficult for the People's Republic of China to be able to contain this virus through their zero COVID strategy,' reads a Monday White House statement in response to anti-lockdown demonstrations that swept through major Chinese cities and university campuses over the weekend. "We've long said everyone has a right to peacefully protest, here in the United States and around the world. This includes the PRC.'

"The latest reports from China say police have flooded into public spaces to prevent fresh demonstrations from breaking out, and they have started to contact suspected rally attendees. The White House's statement seems an attempt to ward off a more serious, violent crackdown, while not giving Chinese Communist officials too much room to claim that demonstrations are being directed from Washington. All things considered, that's a reasonable approach, even if the cautious wording has enraged some conservatives who want Biden to take a harder line.

"Certainly, the statement is a lot more criticism than the White House ever offered of the Canadian government's harsh crackdown on truck drivers protesting a requirement that they be vaccinated in order to reenter their country. Quite the opposite. The Biden administration urged the Canadian government to use whatever means it had to reopen border crossings barricaded by the so-called 'Freedom convoy' and get a handle on the protests. That's according to revelations of an ongoing Canadian inquiry into Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's unprecedented invocation of Canada's Emergencies Act.

"Trudeau's use of the act in February 2022 allowed his government to freeze the bank accounts of protest participants (even if they hadn't been charged, convicted, or even suspected of committing a crime), demand financial information of protestors be turned over to police, and ban even peaceful, non-disruptive public demonstrations. It was an unquestionably authoritarian move that received criticism from across the political spectrum. Conservative Fox News host Tucker Carlson accused Trudeau of declaring a dictatorship. The progressive Canadian Civil Liberties Association called the prime minister's actions 'unnecessary, unjustifiable and unconstitutional'....

"Reporting from Politico on the inquiry into Trudeau's use of emergency powers shows that top-level Biden administration officials, including Department of Homeland Security officials, were in frequent contact with their Canadian counterparts during the trucker protests. They urged a swift end to the demonstrations. The pressure campaign included a call between Biden and Trudeau a few days before the Emergencies Act was invoked. During that call, the prime minister reportedly assured the president that there was a plan to end the protests quickly. U.S. and Canadian officials had even planned to have daily check-in calls about the protests. Once Trudeau activated the Emergencies Act, those never happened. Evidently, Washington had already gotten what it wanted.

"China's 'Zero COVID' policy is a lot stricter and a lot more injurious to people's civil liberties than Canada's vaccine mandate for truckers. But thus far, it seems like the Canadian government's response to its protests has been more sweeping and restrictive. That doesn't mean Canada is generally more authoritarian than Communist-ruled China.... But Trudeau's actions are evidence that progressive, democratically elected governments still struggle with the authoritarian impulse when their control is threatened. It's an impulse the Biden administration was happy to encourage....

"The takeaway from Biden's role in all this is that the president's view of the right to demonstration hinges far more on his own political self-interest than on any principled commitment to free expression. It's also a lesson in how restrictions on freedom in one country can damage it everywhere. Biden embraced an expansive view of his executive powers to effectively mandate vaccines for millions of Americans. That contributed to his support for the suppression of Canadian anti-mandate demonstrations. That support in turn erodes his moral authority to lecture the Chinese government on the right to protest."

Read more: https://reason.com/2022/11/29/bidens-support-for-covid-protests-hinges-on-what-country-theyre-in/

Trudeau Says Protests In China Are Okay... But Not In Canada, TheDC Shorts, Dec. 1, 2022:

Monday, November 28, 2022

Protests in China against Zero Covid regime

Protesters call for Xi to resign amid unprecedented unrest over China's COVID-19 measures | CBC News - Thomson Reuters: 

November 27, 2022 - "Protesters angered by strict COVID-19 measures called for China's powerful leader to resign, a rare rebuke as authorities in at least eight cities struggled to suppress demonstrations Sunday that represent a rare direct challenge to the ruling Communist Party. 

"The wave of civil disobedience is unprecedented in mainland China since President Xi Jinping assumed power a decade ago, as frustration mounts over his signature zero-COVID policy nearly three years into the pandemic.... The protests — which began Friday and have spread to cities including the capital, Beijing, and dozens of university campuses — are the most widespread show of opposition to the ruling party in decades.

  • Police using pepper spray drove away demonstrators in Shanghai who called for Xi to step down and an end to one-party rule, but hours later people rallied again in the same spot. Police again broke up the demonstration.... In a video of the protest in Shanghai verified by The Associated Press, chants against Xi, the most powerful leader since at least the 1980s, and the Chinese Communist Party sounded loud and clear: 'Xi Jinping! Step down! CCP! Step down!' People also held up blank sheets of paper as an expression of protest.
  • A large crowd also gathered in the southwestern metropolis of Chengdu, according to videos on social media, where they also held up blank sheets of paper and chanted: 'We don't want lifelong rulers. We don't want emperors,' a reference to Xi, who has scrapped presidential term limits.
  • At the campus of Beijing's Tsinghua University, a large crowd gathered, according to images and videos posted on social media. Some people also held blank sheets of paper.
  • In the central city of Wuhan, where the pandemic began three years ago, videos on social media showed hundreds of residents take to the streets, smashing through metal barricades, overturning COVID-19 testing tents and demanding an end to lockdowns.
  • Other cities that have seen public dissent include Lanzhou in the northwest, where residents on Saturday overturned COVID-19 staff tents and smashed testing booths, posts on social media showed. Protesters said they were put under lockdown even though no one had tested positive.

"The current protests erupted after a fire broke out Thursday, killing at least 10 people in an apartment building in the city of Urumqi in the northwest, where some have been locked in their homes for four months. That prompted an outpouring of angry questions online about whether firefighters or people trying to escape were blocked by locked doors or other restrictions. Urumqi officials abruptly held a news conference on Saturday to deny that pandemic measures had hampered escape and rescue efforts.

"Three years after COVID-19 emerged, China is the only major country still trying to stop transmission of COVID-19. Its "zero COVID" strategy has suspended access to neighbourhoods for weeks at a time. Some cities carry out daily virus tests on millions of residents.... People who are quarantined at home in some areas say they lack food and medicine. The ruling party faced public anger following the deaths of two children whose parents said anti-virus controls hampered efforts to get medical help.

"China defends its COVID-19 policies as life-saving and necessary to prevent overwhelming the health-care system. Officials have vowed to continue with it despite the growing public pushback and its mounting toll on the world's second-biggest economy."

Read more: https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/china-protest-covid-1.6665822

Sunday, April 10, 2022

Trudeau gov't bigger threat than Freedom Convoy

The Freedom Convoy's Ottawa protest was no threat to Canada's free and democratic system of government, argues Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms president John Carpay. However, the Trudeau  government's response is such a threat.

April 5, 2022 - "Jody Thomas, the Prime Minister's Security and Intelligence Advisor, declared on March 10 that 'there's no doubt' that the people who organized the peaceful protest in Ottawa in February 'came to overthrow the government.' Oddly, Ms. Thomas then goes on to express grave doubt about whether the protesters had the ability to do this, or even knew how to do it. Indeed, the truckers brought neither guns nor tanks, did not storm the Parliament buildings, and made no effort to occupy even one government building. Some individuals called on the prime minister to resign, but nobody used force to try to make that happen.

"Ms. Thomas credits the Emergencies Act with empowering the federal government to freeze bank accounts without a court order or oversight, and to have police horses trample unarmed protesters, 'in a way that we would have not otherwise been able to do.' It appears that, for Ms. Thomas, no measures can be too harsh when suppressing what she describes as 'domestic ideologically motivated violent extremism.'

"Ms. Thomas refers to the February protest as the 'occupation' of downtown Ottawa, although Members of Parliament (and many others) have stated publicly that they had no trouble walking through the city centre each day to get to their place of work. Article 42 of the Hague Convention of 1907 states: 'Territory is considered occupied when it is actually placed under the authority of the hostile army. The occupation extends only to the territory where such authority has been established and can be exercised'.... A large gathering of people in one area does not constitute an 'occupation.' Ms. Thomas also referred to the peaceful protest as a 'blockade,' when in fact the downtown was not in any way sealed off to prevent goods or people from entering or leaving. It was the police, not the protesters, who eventually erected a fence around the downtown core, after the Prime Minister had declared a national emergency. Certainly, some Ottawa residents were inconvenienced by the protests, but this does not turn the protest into a 'blockade.'

"If the protesters had been violent or had committed crimes, the Ottawa Police would have arrested those people, and publicized the arrests. To support the government's narrative.... Yet during the first three weeks of the Ottawa protest, prior to the February 14 declaration of a national emergency, police did not charge any trucker with any crime.... Moreover, if any protester had vandalized, stolen, or burned down property, or had assaulted anyone, or had uttered criminal threats, the CBC and other government-funded media would have gleefully reported on it repeatedly, around the clock, for weeks on end. Why were government-funded media not able to show Canadians footage of protesters committing crimes?...

"The accusations of Ms. Thomas about an 'occupation' and 'blockade' with intent to 'overthrow' Canada's government are as irresponsible and unfounded as the Prime Minister's narrative about unvaccinated Canadians being 'anti-science, racist, misogynist, extremists.'

"There is a dark and very sinister side to accusing peaceful protestors who disagree with certain government policies of wanting to overthrow the government.... A Cambodian court recently convicted 19 political opposition leaders of trying to overthrow the government, a verdict described by Human Rights Watch as bogus.... When Nicaraguan security forces violently put down anti-government protests in 2018, President Daniel Ortega claimed the protests were actually an attempted coup with foreign backing, and that foreign-funded organizations were part of a broader conspiracy to remove him from office.... Ugandan dictator Idi Amin, whose regime murdered an estimated 300,000 Ugandans during his eight-year reign of terror, was very offended when Archbishop Janani Luwum publicly criticized the government's violence. Well, you guessed it: Idi Amin accused this archbishop of seeking to overthrow the government. Archbishop Luwum was arrested in February 1977 and died shortly after....

"Thus far, opponents of Prime Minister Trudeau have not been murdered and have not been jailed for long periods of time. But demonizing the unvaccinated minority, accusing opponents of wanting to overthrow the government, freezing bank accounts without a court order, and commencing criminal prosecutions against peaceful protesters are clear and direct threats to the survival of Canada as a free and democratic society."

John Carpay is president of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (jccf.ca), whose clients include truckers who peacefully protested in Ottawa in February.

Friday, April 8, 2022

Ottawa arsonists not linked to Freedom Convoy

Police charge 2nd man in arson during Ottawa convoy protest | CBC News:

April 6, 2022 - "A second man has been charged after an attempted arson in a downtown Ottawa apartment building during the so-called Freedom Convoy, but police again say they haven't uncovered anything linking the accused with the protest. The incident on Lisgar Street Feb. 6 prompted city politicians and some of the building's residents to link the event to the protest, which occupied streets in front of Parliament Hill and angered downtown residents for more than three weeks.

"On March 21, ... Ottawa police charged a 21-year-old Ottawa man in connection with the incident and said they were hoping to identify a second suspect. On Wednesday, police said a 41-year-old Ottawa man is facing the same set of charges as the 21-year-old: arson with disregard for human life, arson causing property damage, mischief to property, mischief to property endangering life, and possessing incendiary material. In news releases announcing both sets of charges, police said there is 'no information' indicating the men were 'involved in any way' with the protest.... 

"[Ottawa] Mayor Jim Watson included the arson in a list of incidents of harassment against residents and disruptions he blamed on the ongoing protest. Coun. Diane Deans also cited an alleged detail from witnesses — that the front door was duct-taped to prevent those outside from entering the building — which she said showed the escalation of protester tactics knew no bounds."

Read more: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/apartment-building-lisgar-arson-second-man-charged-1.6410506

How the Liberals and NDP pushed the arson hoax about the Freedom Convoy | True North - Cosmin Dzsurdzsa:

April 7, 2022 - "Despite the now undeniable absolution of the Freedom Convoy of an alleged attempt to burn down a building full of entrapped residents, the governing Ottawa establishment seems to have been replaced with crickets.... Throughout February, Liberal and NDP MPs (alongside the legacy media establishment) continued to insinuate that protesters had been involved in the incident, if not actually accuse them of responsibility. The false claims not only litter the Hansard records of debate and committee proceedings in the House of Commons, but they were also repeated on social media and by pundits opining on the evils of the anti-restrictions protesters who had gathered in the capital. 

"NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh was the first to introduce the false accusation to the official record when he pointed to the incident as an 'example' of the so-called commonplace violence at the protests. 'We saw an example of this violence with an attempted arson of a downtown apartment building, where people started a fire and taped the doors closed when they exited. I ask members to take a moment to think what that means. They had the forethought to set a fire and then tape the doors so no one could escape,' said Singh on Feb. 7. 

"The accusation was solidified when the Liberals called for a unanimous consent motion calling on the House to condemn 'the arson attempts … by protesters on the streets of Ottawa.' When the motion failed to pass without the support of the Conservatives, Liberal MP and attack dog Mark Gerretsen used it to beat the official opposition over the brow and accuse them of not wanting the protest to end. 'They knew what they were saying no to. One lone Conservative over there, obviously set up by the whip’s desk, probably with their head down, said no and rejected the unanimous consent motion on behalf of the Leader of the Opposition,' claimed Gerretsen. 'It is clear that she does not want the protest to end for the same reasons the rest of the country does.'

"The examples are too many to include in one article, but the same claims were repeated by MPs Sameer Zuberi (Lib.), Matthew Green (NDP), Arif Virani (Lib.), Francisco Sorbara (Lib.), Alistair MacGregor (NDP), Anita Vandenbeld (Lib.), Laurel Collins (NDP), Ron McKinnon (Lib.), Jennifer O’Connell (Lib.), Ryan Turnbull (Lib.), Parm Bains (Lib.), Jenny Kwan (NDP), Andy Fillmore (Lib.), Peter Schlefke (Lib.) and Gord Johns (NDP).... 

"The push to pin the attempted arson in Ottawa onto the Freedom Convoy betrays how much the government has and continues to rely on shoddy reporting and even social media to leap into action.... [T]he arson was immediately pinned to the convoy by a local resident who clearly had a gripe with the protest movement and its goals....  Without further investigation, politicians took this claim and ran with it.... Looking through the parliamentary debate, it is clear that a hoax played a key role in justifying Trudeau’s first-ever use of the Emergencies Act, potentially setting a precedent for the regular use of government emergency powers to quash protests that are politically inconvenient."

Read more: https://tnc.news/2022/04/07/dzsurdzsa-how-the-liberals-and-ndp-pushed-the-arson-hoax-about-the-freedom-convoy/

Thursday, March 31, 2022

Ontario anti-lockdown MPP freed on bail

Randy Hillier gets bail – but also gets silenced | Western Standard - Karen Selick: 


Hillier at 2021 anti-lockdown protest, Niagara Falls, Ont, Photo: Beth Baisch, Dreamstime

March 29, 2022 -"I’ve known Ontario MPP Randy Hillier for about 20 years. I’ve found myself in agreement with him on every important issue I can think of over that time. The pandemic was no exception. I admired his courage in publicly opposing Ontario’s official government narrative about lockdowns, mask mandates and vaccination mandates. I applauded his denunciation of the tyrannical federal policies that led to the Ottawa Freedom Convoy. 

"Therefore, when I received a message early Monday morning (March 28) saying that Randy was being charged with nine Criminal Code offences ... and would be surrendering to the Ottawa police that day, I was alarmed. I knew he had been accumulating provincial charges for various No More Lockdowns protests he had organized and attended around the province, but sources have been telling me that many charges of this kind are being delayed and ultimately dropped by prosecutors who don’t want to face a well-thought-out Charter challenge. Criminal Code charges by the Ottawa police were a different kettle of fish. My concern, of course, was Randy might face the kind of treatment that had been given to convoy organizer Tamara Lich, who spent two weeks in jail before finally receiving reasonable bail conditions.

"Randy retained Ottawa criminal lawyer David Anber, and a bail hearing was held via Zoom on Monday afternoon. Anber had already negotiated with Crown counsel Tim Wightman and they had hammered out an agreement under which Randy would be released on bail subject to 15 conditions he’d have to comply with. Counsel were able to agree on the wording of 14 of those conditions: standard bail terms such as posting a bond (in this case, $35,000), residing with his surety at a fixed address, not communicating with other people who have been charged with offences also arising out of the Freedom Convoy, and so on. However, they couldn’t agree on the wording of the fifteenth condition, namely what Randy would be permitted to say on social media pending trial about the issues he has been expounding on over the past two years.

"I managed to get into the Zoom call and listened to the legal arguments. The Crown wanted to restrict Randy from posting anything 'on social media of any type' regarding not only the Freedom Convoy, but also provincial policy on mask mandates, vaccination mandates, 'or the Anti-vaccine cause [sic].' He also wanted to prevent Randy from attending or providing 'any type of support (including financial support) to the freedom convoy or any anti mask/vaccine organization or causes [sic].' Anber pointed out as an elected member of the legislature, it was actually Randy’s job to comment precisely on important issues like this before the legislature. He also argued that in a free and democratic society, it’s important to have competing voices saying different things about the issues.

"The Crown prosecutor then seemed to narrow down what he was asking for. It’s forbidden on Ontario court Zoom calls to make your own recordings of the proceedings, so I had to type furiously in an effort to catch what he was saying. He seemed to concede that the wording of the disputed bail condition would not prevent Randy from making his views heard in the mainstream media or in the legislature only on social media, which the Crown described as his primary tool of communication.

"This isn’t much comfort. For starters, how is social media defined nowadays? I no longer get paper copies of major daily newspapers delivered to my door. I read them online, and frequently participate in the online comment sections. Does the electronic interaction between a newspaper and its readers nudge the paper over the line into the social media category? Is clicking a 'like' button part of 'posting?' What about sharing someone else’s post? It’s not entirely clear what will be forbidden, and the stakes would be high if Randy were to be accused of violating his bail conditions. But more importantly, I can’t see the difference in 'risk to the public' between the two types of media.....

"Justice of the Peace Logue took only a 10-minute break before deciding in favour of the Crown, demonstrating she has apparently bought the government’s pandemic narrative hook, line and sinker. Although she paid lip service to the Charter, she gave short shrift to Randy’s freedom of expression and freedom of assembly. Randy and his lawyer are contemplating whether or not to appeal.

"Meanwhile, there’s one other aspect of the bail hearing that struck me as grossly unfair.... When Randy was brought into the call at the end from his jail cell to be asked whether he accepted the conditions the judge had ordered, it was apparent that the police officer had just brought him to the phone for that purpose, and he hadn’t been allowed to listen to or watch the entire proceedings. Accused people can normally attend their bail hearings, which allows them to listen carefully to the allegations being made against them by the Crown, inform their lawyer of any important points he or she might need to know, and evaluate their own lawyer’s performance in the courtroom. Randy was denied the benefit of all of these."

Read more: https://westernstandardonline.com/2022/03/selick-randy-hillier-gets-bail-but-also-gets-silenced/

Saturday, March 19, 2022

Critics' hysteria helped Freedom Convoy

Canada’s ‘Freedom Convoy’ was on a path to nowhere — until its critics overplayed their hand | Foundation against Intolerance and Racism - Jonathan Kay:

Maksim Sokolov  Freedom Convoy protesters, Ottawa, Feb. 12, 2022. CC BY-SA, Wikimedia Commons.

February 12, 2020 - "I can always tell when Canadian political news gets exciting, because these are the rare moments when foreign media outlets email me for commentary.... I’ve been asked for comment on Canadian truckers’ “freedom convoy” by the Washington Post, a Spanish-language radio network, and even a podcast based in Hanoi. Certainly, The New York Times has taken notice, grimly warning its readership of the 'far-right activists' embracing the truckers’ cause.

"There is certainly a grain of truth to the Times’ description. The convoy was originally conceived as a way to fight back against government rules mandating the vaccination of cross-border truckers. But some of the organizers were populist radicals, and there have been sporadic sightings of extreme right-wing symbols at the protests (even if the paucity of these embarrassing outliers seems to have disappointed the left-of-center pundits and politicians who were primed to treat the convoy’s arrival in Ottawa as Canada’s version of the January 6th Capitol riot).

"As I wrote in the National Post, there was no real reason to think this kind of disruptive stunt was going to be a successful act of protest. In early days, many of us associated the whole project with anti-vaccine activism (even if, technically, this was about mandates, not vaccination itself), a highly unpopular cause in Canada.... My own perspective in late January was pretty typical of most urbanites, I think: I live in a Toronto neighborhood where people get antsy if someone so much as double-parks a minivan for more than 10 minutes. I can’t imagine how much my neighbors and I would be freaking out if a whole truck convoy were lining our streets honking their horns. And so it didn’t surprise me when an early national poll showed that most Canadians didn’t have much time for the convoy.

"But something interesting happened.... Progressive critics of the convoy badly overplayed their hand, and their own divisive rhetoric became a story in itself. Social media has played a huge role in this: The depiction of the protestors as uniformly malevolent actors (and even white supremacists) has been deeply undercut by viral images of joyous and multicultural protest parties. Moreover, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s refusal to meet with the protestors (due to what he calls their 'hateful rhetoric') has earned him a clear (if implicit) public rebuke from an MP within his own party.... 

"On Tuesday [February 10], Liberal MP Joël Lightbound said, 'it’s time to stop dividing Canadians, to stop pitting one part of the population against another. I can’t help but notice with regret that both tone and the policies of my government changed drastically on the eve and during the last election campaign. From a positive and unifying approach, a decision was made to wedge to divide, and to stigmatize.' While Lightbound also threw in abundant denunciations of the radicalism evinced by some protestors, he also pointedly noted that some of their specific grievances — he named 'the vaccine requirement for truckers' explicitly — weren’t exactly crazy: 'If we forget about the demonstrations, and we forget about the convoy for just a second, and look at that policy for what it is. This is a policy that now goes against the World Health Organization’s recommendation and for which no epidemiological studies and projections have been provided.'

"We are witnessing what I believe is a significant inflection point in Canada’s political timeline — though I offer no predictions for what will become of it. Just a few months ago, when fear of Omicron ran hot, and the fight against COVID was still seen as a matter of great urgency, the freedom convoy wouldn’t have had a chance in the Canadian court of public opinion. But things have changed a lot since December, and provincial governments are starting to dismantle their lockdown measures without waiting for Trudeau’s blessing. As a result, the political taint associated with vaccine skepticism — which has, until now, throttled the forces of populist agitation on the Canadian right — has ebbed. Even many vaccinated-and-boosted centrist Canadians (I’d put myself in that category) are eager to get on with post-pandemic life, and don’t have much time for the hectoring of double-masked puritans who denounce all strong political dissent as emanating from (in Trudeau’s words) 'misogynists and racists'....

There are other signs that change is in the air, too.... Even the leadership of the CBC, which typically lumbers along obliviously in its own hyper-progressive taxpayer-bankrolled media silo, now seems somewhat dumbstruck by its inability to shape the country’s political narrative. In a February 8 essay, CBC News editor-in-chief Brodie Fenlon rightly denounced the harassment that some of his colleagues are now facing from angry viewers and listeners, while also channeling incredulity that there are those who 'harbor a deep and growing distrust of news organizations like ours.' This lack of institutional self-awareness is quite stunning. And if the blistering replies that his article elicited are any guide, even many Canadian leftists are becoming alienated by legacy media cliques that now operate as little more than relay stations for increasingly dubious orthodoxies about race, sex, and politics.

"The wild card here is the Conservative Party of Canada, which vies with the Liberals for power every time a federal election is called. Its affable leader, Erin O’Toole, fell victim to an internal revolt.... O’Toole had spent the last previous two years steering the Conservatives on a respectable center-right course, studiously avoiding any posture that the Canadian media might be able to seize upon as evidence of Trumpism. In part thanks to the convoy’s disruptive effect on Canada’s normally placid political order, it seems doubtful that his leadership replacement will find this kind of risk-averse strategy to be viable. No matter how Canadians feel about the convoy, there’s no doubt that these truckers have made their mark on the political direction of their country."

Read more: https://fairforall.substack.com/p/canadas-freedom-convoy?s=r 

Friday, March 4, 2022

FBI encouraged, directed Whitmer kidnapping plot

The Gretchen Whitmer Kidnapping Plot Looks an Awful Lot Like Entrapment | Reason - Robby Soave: 

January 26, 2022 - "The militia members who allegedly plotted to kidnap Michigan's Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer because of her COVID-19 lockdown policies will go to trial in just a few weeks. Six were charged in connection with the plot, and one of them has already pleaded guilty and is expected to testify against the rest. State authorities charged eight others with aiding a terrorist plot.

"But the government's case against these 14 alleged extremists relies on work done by at least a dozen government informants and undercover FBI agents whose extensive involvement in the plot calls into question whether it would have moved forward at all without the government's prodding. Some of these government actors took lead roles in organizing the supposed plot — one of the informants was even paid $54,000 by the FBI. Taken together, these and other details raise the strong possibility that the militia members were victims of entrapment....

"The FBI Investigation Into The Alleged Plot To Kidnap Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer Has Gotten Very Complicated," conceded BuzzFeed News in an in-depth examination of the available evidence published last month. And earlier this week, The New York Times acknowledged that the involvement of informants and agents had 'muddled' the case:

On a rainy night in northern Michigan in September 2020, a group of armed men divided among three cars surveyed the landscape around the vacation cottage of Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, considering how to kidnap her as payback for her Covid-19 lockdown measures.... 
Later, after team members returned to the rural camp where they had already conducted military-style training exercises, a man identified as "Big Dan" in government documents asked the assembled group, "Everybody down with what's going on?" Another man responded, "If you are not down with the thought of kidnapping, don't sit here."
Of the dozen men on that nighttime surveillance mission, four of them including "Big Dan" were either government informants or undercover F.B.I. agents, according to court documents.

"'Big Dan' was no passive spectator: After initially alerting the authorities that he was involved in a Facebook group for militia members in which violence against police officers had been discussed, he agreed to become an informant. The government paid him $54,000 for six months' work. When the militia group surveilled Whitmer's vacation home, it was Big Dan leading the charge. According to the group's defense attorneys, Big Dan — an Iraq War veteran — took charge of training the other men in military tactics....

"Big Dan's FBI handler, Jayson Chambers, ... was attempting to build a security consulting business in the midst of the investigation.... BuzzFeed obtained a resume that Chambers had shared with prospective clients, and in that document, he took credit for using 'online undercover techniques' to investigate terrorist groups. According to BuzzFeed, Chambers has a long history of participating in FBI investigations of Muslim youths who were enticed by law enforcement to become involved in wholly theoretical violent plots, according to their defense attorneys. Chambers is no longer slated to participate in the trial. Another government asset, Stephen Robeson, worked as an informant during the investigation, but is no longer involved after pleading guilty to various felonies. And the government's star witness, FBI Agent Robert Trask, was fired by the agency after beating his wife.... 

"The court may determine that none of this matters.... Historically, victims of entrapment have had a tough time prevailing, no matter how duplicitously the FBI behaved. But in any case, it is now clear that Whitmer was in no real danger. At all stages of the alleged plot, the FBI was aware of every facet: Their agents and informants were intimately involved — not just surveilling the militia members, but actively offering guidance on how to pull off the kidnapping.... 

"Many conservatives have become committed to the idea that the January 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol was not the work of Trump supporters, but rather, elements of the so-called Deep State.... The Whitmer kidnapping plot ... was extensively directed and encouraged by agents of the government. It's a much, much, much, much more persuasive case of Deep State nefariousness."

Read more: https://reason.com/2022/01/26/gretchen-whitmer-kidnapping-plot-entrapment-fbi-trial/

Saturday, February 26, 2022

Majority of Canadians 18-54 approved of Freedom Convoy

One Canadian pollster found that a "small fringe majority" of Canadians aged 18-54 sympathized with the Freedom Convoy, while the overwhelming majority of their elders opposed it.   

Trudeau’s convoy response gets failing grade, but even fewer support protesters: Ipsos poll | Global News - Aya Al-Hakim:

February 24, 2022 - "As the so-called “Freedom Convoy” comes to an end in Ottawa, Canadians remain divided on how they feel about the protests. According to a new Ipsos poll published Thursday, Canadians’ approval of Justin Trudeau’s handling of the convoy blockade was only seven points higher than that of the protesters. 

"The poll conducted exclusively for Global News showed that 43 per cent of Canadians approved of the way Trudeau handled the three-week long protests in Ottawa while 36 per cent per cent supported the way the truckers handled themselves throughout the occupation. In Ontario ... 49 per cent approved of Doug Ford’s handling of the situation, narrowly beating the 46 per cent who approved of Trudeau’s performance.

"'What’s particularly worrying is that 52 per cent of the people that we interviewed said that the prime minister’s divisive rhetoric and the way that he approached the protest was mostly responsible for what happened,' Darrell Bricker, CEO of Ipsos public affairs, told Global News. Bricker explained that Trudeau characterized people who were part of the protest as the ones who voted for the opposition parties, particularly the People’s Party and the Conservative Party, but 'the data shows that people aren’t particularly united around any sort of partisan choice.' 

"'This is really a group of the population…who really are feeling left out, left behind and very concerned about the way that the government is not only managing the pandemic, but also the way that the economy is going right now,' said Bricker. 'They have a very challenged sense of hope. But it’s not defined in partisan terms. The prime minister chose to define it in those terms, and the reaction from the public to that has been quite negative. As we’ve seen in the polling results, 52 per cent of the population said he added fuel to the fire,' he added.

"According to the poll, nearly 46 per cent say that while they may not agree with everything that the convoy participants have said and done in Ottawa, their frustration is legitimate and worthy of people’s sympathy. 'So as bad as things got during the course of the protest, it really didn’t affect how people felt about the protesters themselves,' Bricker said.

"About 48 per cent of people also said that the protest probably wouldn’t have taken place if people weren’t feeling the level of economic frustration that they’re feeling. On top of that, 54 per cent of Canadians also believe the protests in Ottawa at least partially contributed to the loosening of COVID-19 restrictions in the country.

"Bricker said the issue here is that 'even though authorities may not like it,' data is showing that protesters have gained a certain amount of sympathy among the Canadian population.

"The poll also states that 'a deep generational divide is evident,' with a majority of those aged 18-34 (58 per cent) and 35-54 (53 per cent) sympathizing with the protesters compared to only 32 per cent of those aged over 55. Bricker said that younger Canadians are feeling very insecure in this economy and are sympathizing more with the frustration that the convoy is presenting compared to older Canadians and those who are more economically secure. 'Usually, we see things through a partisan lens or we see them through a regional lens. Not this time. It’s a different type of division that we’re seeing,' he said.

Read more: https://globalnews.ca/news/8640772/ipsos-poll-trudeau-convoy-response/

Saturday, February 12, 2022

The Power of Protest

The Power of Protest | Brownstone Institute - Jeffrey A. Tucker:

February 3, 2022 - "Israel has repealed [Covid] restrictions and is backing off vaccine mandates, even as cases and deaths are hitting new highs, and implausibly so in the most vaccinated and boosted country in the world. The UK has backed off too. Same in Denmark, Ireland, Finland, and Norway. Switzerland has joined in, and Sweden has rolled back its plans for an extended vaccine passport [and] has decided to get rid of them completely. Saskatchewan is ending all restrictions. We are seeing local governments and universities in the US gradually stepping back. No new cities have joined the brigade for vaccine passports and Denver, CO, is stopping theirs....

"Monmouth University tracks attitudes in the US toward government and media as it pertains to the pandemic response. At this point, every arrow over time slants down to the right. The number of people opposing vaccine passports outnumbers those supporting them by 10 points. A polled 70% say it is time we accept Covid as normal....

"It is surely not a coincidence that all of this accelerated the same week as the trucker convoy formed in Vancouver and made the trek across ... Canada ... in the snow, ending up in Ottawa and gathering many tens of thousands of citizens to protest. The Prime Minister fled the city and went to his bunker, making what looked like hostage videos that denounced the truckers with all the usual epithets. 

Crowds cheered Freedom Convoy Canada, January 27, 2022. Photo by Rise of the Dots! CC BY, Wikimedia Commons

"What’s even more striking is that the media in the US and Europe did not cover the convoy, probably the largest in history and certainly the most important protest in modern times in Canada. The topic never ended up on the front page of either the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal. And yet: the effect was hugely powerful. Public opinion in Canada swung 15% to create a solid majority against all restrictions and mandates.... And other governments around the world are paying attention.... They are backing down, more already in Europe than the US. But even in US blue states, you can see evidence that the basis for restrictions and mandates is falling apart. Let’s also mention New Zealand, the island nation that pretended it would somehow magically make the virus go away. Now with wave after wave of cases, even the crazy Jacinda Ardern is rolling back quarantine mandates and gradually reopening the country. 

"The great slogan is 'living with Covid.' It is an implicit repudiation of everything that has happened for two years. It’s what we should have done all along. But the fanatics took over. The hysterical scream back in 2020 was that the power of the state, backed by media and corporate interests, would somehow make the virus go away. It was always ridiculously unachievable. The attempt unleashed massive abuse against the population, disrupted economies everywhere, and unleashed a tremendous amount of financial corruption that is still going on today. 

"We are nowhere near done with this. Massive restrictions are still in place. Travel is still a disaster. The mask mandate on transportation is as awful as ever. The segregation in DC, NYC, and Boston is morally repulsive. Plus, so many lives have been shattered. So many businesses have closed. Public health is in shambles. The demographic disruption has been profound. There are scandals lurking everywhere. What exactly were Fauci, Farrar, and Collins doing the whole of February 2020 instead of examining ways that sick people could get well? Why did they use burner phones? And that article debunking the lab leak in Nature, the one highly criticized later. How did that come about?

"Mysteries abound about the vaccine trials. And wait until people have a look at the “Emergency Use Approval” documents submitted by the manufacturers. They will discover that the pharma companies never promised much at all. They certainly never said that the vaxx would stop the spread, keep people from being infected, much less end the pandemic. They never said that it would work against variants.... 

"Governments spent many trillions of dollars, most of which ended up in the pockets of well-connected elites in the corporate and banking sectors. The payoffs and graft connected with everything, from testing kits, to masks, to therapeutics will be alarming to behold. And wait until people figure out that all along we might have had solid generics that have a massive effective impact on early treatment. 

"All wars come to an end, but governments rarely think in advance about the exit strategy. Instead, they kill and destroy until exhaustion sets in and then try to sneak away hoping that everyone will just move on. That’s pretty much how things fared with the Iraq War, and the results were devastating for the whole world. There are analogies to how governments are sneaking away from the catastrophe of the last two years. It’s been a war on people, a war on reality, and an attack on rights and liberties on a scale and scope that is without precedent in the modern age. None of it worked. Indeed, that is incredibly obvious now, and wholly humiliating and discrediting for vast swaths of the ruling class. 

"What kind of world emerges on the other side? There will be hatred against experts, elites, governments, media, pharmaceuticals, politicians, and deep-state bureaucrats. It’s already happening. And think of this: if it can happen in Canada, it can happen anywhere. Who would have imagined that it would be Canadian truckers who would step up and save the world?

"It’s a lesson to all of us. It shows that only an active minority of people can make a massive difference, if they speak with moral conviction and courage. Everyone else follows, provided the message is clear and speaks to the reality all around us.

"That, in a nutshell, is the case against despair. There is tremendous virtue right now in staying patient and letting the chips fall exactly where they have begun to fall. Yes, resignations would be ideal but regardless there will be a political realignment and a cultural rethinking. Freedom can win in the long run. And the world will be rebuilt, on a much more solid foundation than was present two years ago. We tried an experiment in tyranny. It flopped. Despite the enormous cost of what took place, we will all find ourselves in a good position to see a rebirth of liberty, human rights, and prosperity on the other side."

Read more: https://brownstone.org/articles/the-power-of-protest/


This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Thursday, February 10, 2022

Freedom Convoy protests spread around world

‘Snowball effect’: Canada’s trucker convoy sparks anti-mandate protests globally | Global News - Saba Aziz [stress added]:

February 9, 2022 - "Since Jan. 28, a convoy of vehicles, mostly trucks, has been parked around [Canada's] Parliament Hill.... Many in the hundreds of vehicles have vowed to stay until all COVID-19 restrictions, including mask and vaccination mandates, are lifted. As the Canadian truckers — many with families and children — continue to clog Ottawa’s streets, anti-vaccine mandate protests in several other countries have also picked up steam....

"Inspired by the Canadian truckers, French protesters set out from southern France on Wednesday in what they call a 'freedom convoy' that will converge on Paris and Brussels — headquarters of the European Union — to demand an end to COVID-19 restrictions. About 200 protesters assembled in a parking lot in Nice, on France’s Mediterranean coast, with many displaying Canadian flags in a nod to the truckers in Canada. The protesters in Nice said they are demanding, among other things, the scrapping of rules barring people from public venues if they do not have a COVID-19 vaccination. Not all of the people setting out from Nice planned to travel all the way to Paris or Brussels. The convoy was made up of motorcycles and private cars, but no trucks.

"In the city of Perpignan, near France’s border with Spain, around 200 people gathered to set off towards Paris as part of the 'freedom convoy' movement. Their convoy was made up of cars, some camper vans, and one heavy-goods vehicle.

"In the Australian capital, the 'Convoy to Canberra' rally against mandatory COVID-19 vaccinations has attracted protesters from across the country. Over the past week, hundreds of cars and trucks have blocked roads and targeted businesses in the city.

"Meanwhile, in Wellington, New Zealand, more than 1,000 people driving cars and trucks from around the country converged on Parliament Tuesday to protest against COVID-19 mandates. Among the protesters’ grievances is the requirement in New Zealand that certain workers get vaccinated against COVID-19, including teachers, doctors, nurses, police and military personnel.... New Zealand police said in a statement they have arrested more than 50 people who face charges including trespassing and obstruction, and will be bailed to appear in court.

"Across the border in the United States, an American version of Canada’s trucker convoy is planning a similar demonstration against COVID-19 mandates. Organizers of the 'The People’s Convoy' plan to kickstart their protest from Coachella Valley in Indio, Cali., on Mar. 4 and head towards Washington, D.C. 'Our brothers and sisters of the highway succeeded in opening Canadian’s eyes about the unconstitutional mandates and hardships forced onto their people and now it’s time for the citizens of the United States of America to unite and demand restoration of our constitutional right,' a statement posted on the group’s Facebook page said on Wednesday."

Read more: https://globalnews.ca/news/8608477/freedom-convoy-worldwide-covid-protests/  

Tuesday, February 8, 2022

Freedom Convoy crowdfunding continuing

Frozen out of GoFundMe, Canadian protest convoy raises millions on Christian site | Washington Post - Paulina Villegas and Reis Thebault:

February 7, 2022 - "After being denied several million dollars raised on GoFundMe, organizers of a trucker-led protest disrupting life in Canada’s capital have found a new platform: a Christian crowdfunding site where they raised more than $3.5 million in two days to demonstrate against the country’s vaccine mandate. The new fundraiser hosted by GiveSendGo, which describes itself as the '#1 free Christian crowdfunding site,' reported Sunday that the 'Freedom Convoy' campaign had raised several million dollars two days after GoFundMe announced that it was freezing more than $8 million in donations to the cause....

"GoFundMe said Friday that it had removed a fundraiser for the convoy that had raised more than $8 million because it violated its terms of service. The company said it had released an initial $1 million in donations to Freedom Convoy organizers last week after they provided a clear distribution plan and confirmed that they would only be used for those participating in a peaceful protest. But after receiving evidence from law enforcement that the 'previously peaceful demonstration has become an occupation,' the company said no additional funds would be distributed to its organizers and instead donors would have two weeks to submit a request for a refund, the company said. GoFundMe then would work with convoy organizers to send the remaining money to other charities.

"GoFundMe’s decision aroused conservative ire on both sides of the border, drawing special scrutiny from several Republican attorneys general, who pledged to investigate the platform. On Friday evening ... West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey (R) asked residents who have 'been victimized by a deceptive act or practice' to report it.... By Sunday, at least four other states — Florida, Louisiana, Ohio and Texas — had done just that, promising to investigate GoFundMe for allegedly deceptive practices. The threats of an investigation continued even after the platform announced Saturday that it would refund all contributions automatically amid the donor backlash. The company did not respond to an inquiry Sunday from The Washington Post."
Read more: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/02/07/canada-protesters-fundraising-platform/

illustration courtesy TallyCoin

This is just gonna explode’: How Bitcoin bigwigs’ ‘HonkHonk’ came to fundraise for Canada’s ‘Freedom convoy’ | Toronto Star - Alex McKeen:

February 7, 2022 - "Bitcoin investors who want to 'orange pill' the world and create a financial system outside of government regulation are rallying to join forces with — and raise money for — the 'Freedom convoy' protest in Canada. The group of five men will exclusively control the donations — which have so far reached around $500,000 CAD — and they say they want to show that cryptocurrencies are the libertarian money of the future....

"Greg Foss, Jeff Booth and two other men who go by the pseudonyms BTC Sessions and Nobody Cariboo all invest in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, and create videos, books and online courses promoting cryptocurrency as a key component of a future financial system that is free from government oversight. Now, they’ve teamed up with B.J. Dichter, one of the original organizers of the Freedom Convoy to Ottawa — and pulled in donations from cryptocurrency-rich investors known as 'whales' — to raise money for the protest’s anti vaccine-mandate and anti-restrictions cause.... The bitcoin fundraiser is being hosted on the website TallyCoin and has attracted more than 4,000 donors....

"The convoy, which has been carrying on an occupation-style protest in Ottawa for 11 days, and has inspired other anti-mandate protests across the country, had raised more than $10 million on the fundraising platform GoFundMe. It was started by Alberta woman Tamara Lich, with Dichter having been added later as another organizer. GoFundMe cancelled the fundraiser, however, after Ottawa police contacted the platform.... The cancellation of the fundraiser ... created an immediate backlash from supporters of the convoy, as well as a host of American right-wing politicians, including Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, who said it was evidence of bias from GoFundMe. It also appears to have been a launching pad for Bitcoiners promoting their own anti-establishment messages.

"Two days before the GoFundMe was cancelled on Feb 4, an online personality known as “HonkHonk Hodl” had set up an alternative fundraiser — and its pitch for 'censorship resistant' fundraising using Bitcoin started to take off. On Sunday evening, the fund even got a donation of an entire Bitcoin, more than $50,000 CAD from Jesse Powell, who heads Kraken, one of the highest value cryptocurrency exchanges in the world....

"Foss, 58, is from Oakville, Ont., and had a long career in the financial industry before retiring and diving headfirst into Bitcoin enthusiasm. 'I believe it to be the most beautiful financial and technological innovation I’ve ever seen,' he told the Star in an interview Monday. 'And it was made for situations like this weekend, where you have a centralized platform that decides upon on their own volition that the funds raised on that platform are not going to be distributed to the people that the funds were raised for. And it’s very scary.'"
Read more: https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2022/02/07/this-is-just-gonna-explode-how-bitcoin-bigwigs-honkhonk-came-to-fundraise-for-canadas-freedom-convoy.html

Monday, February 7, 2022

Freedom Convoy's one condition for ending its Ottawa protest

Justice Centre lawyers in Ottawa representing Freedom Convoy truckers | True North - Jonathan Bradley:

February 3, 2022 - "The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (JCCF) is now representing the Freedom Convoy organizers and has a team of lawyers on the ground in Ottawa to provide legal assistance. JCCF constitutional lawyer Keith Wilson gave a press conference on Thursday in the nation’s capital alongside convoy organizers.  

"According to [organizer Tamara] Lich, accountants and lawyers working for the convoy have been communicating with GoFundMe, who said it stopped the truck convoy’s crowdfunding page on Wednesday.... Wilson said that most of the money is being held by GoFundMe because they were 'bombarded with an orchestrated social media campaign to try and shut it down.' He said that all of the legal and accounting requirements have been met.... The funds raised by the GofundMe at the time of the suspension had reached almost $10.1 million....

"Lich had begun the press conference by reiterating the purpose of the freedom convoy.

"'We are calling on all levels of government in Canada to end all COVID mandates and restrictions,' said convoy co-organizer Tamara Lich. 'We will continue our protest until we see a clear plan for their elimination.'

[Lich told those in attendance that "As of today, Sweden, Denmark, UK, Norway, Finland, Ireland, and Switzerland have removed all Covid mandates and restrictions." She praised Saskatchewan premier Scott Moe for showing "leadership" by pledging to do likewise, adding that "hopefully these words will turn into long-lasting actions." She thanked the people of Ottawa who have supported the convoy, and assured them that ""we have no intention of staying one day longer than necessary. Our departure will be based on the Prime Minister doing what is right: ending all mandates and restrictions on our freedom."  - gd]

"Lich said that so far, no one from the Canadian, Ontario or Ottawa governments has spoken with them.  She said that the governments are instead using the media to portray the truckers as 'racists, misogynists and even terrorists.' Lich said that as a Métis woman, she is offended by these allegations. She added that the truckers are 'average, peace-loving and law-abiding citizens from all walks of life who are fed up with being disrespected and bullied by our government.' 

"The protest entered its twelfth day on Thursday. The scene on the ground was peaceful on the eleventh day, with protestors singing and dancing for most of the day while free food and coffee was served up at every block on the closed stretch of Wellington Street."

Read more: https://tnc.news/2022/02/03/justice-centre-lawyers-in-ottawa-representing-freedom-convoy-truckers/