Showing posts with label Coutts 4. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Coutts 4. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 16, 2025

Chris Carbert granted bail pending appeal

2022 Coutts protester Chris Carbert has been granted bail pending his appeal of his 2024 conviction and sentence.

Coutts blockade leader granted bail pending appeal of convictions, sentence | CBC News | Meghan Grant:


Chris Carbert. Photo Bridge City News.

June 30, 2025 - "One of the men serving a sentence for convictions connected to the 2022 Coutts border blockade has been granted bail pending his appeal. Chris Carbert is serving a 6½-year sentence for mischief over $5,000 and possession of a weapon for a dangerous purpose. He has appealed his convictions and sentence. 

On Monday, Alberta Court of Appeal Justice Jo-Anne Strekaf ruled Carbert can be released pending his conviction appeal arguments, which are set to be heard in September. 'Detention pending his appeals is not necessary for the protection or safety of the public,' wrote Strekaf in her 10-page decision.... Strekaf ordered Carbert's lawyer Katherin Beyak and prosecutors to appear before her with a release plan. Carbert was convicted alongside Anthony Olienick, who was handed the same sentence in 2024. Both men were acquitted on the more serious charge of conspiracy to murder RCMP officers.... 

"With credit for the time he spent in custody pending trial, Carbert had two years, seven months left to serve when he was sentenced in September 2024. Carbert is eligible for statutory release in June 2026 and his prison sentence will expire in April 2027. 

"Strekaf cited the Corrections Services Canada assessment completed for the purposes of Carbert's parole hearing which found he is a low risk to reoffend and has support from three prison workers; an officer, the chaplain and the shop instructor. '[Carbert] has demonstrated that there is no substantial likelihood that he will commit a criminal offence or interfere with the administration of justice if released from detention pending the hearing of his appeals,' wrote the judge. 

"Strekaf also noted that both Carbert's conviction and sentence appeals may not be completed until after his mandatory release date. 'In effect, if he remains in custody, he may have served most, if not all, of his sentence regardless of the outcome of his appeals,' wrote the judge."

Read more: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/coutts-blockade-protesters-carbert-bail-pending-appeal-1.7574336

Coutts protester Chris Carbert granted bail pending appeal | July 2, 2025 | Landon Hickok | Bridge City News | July 2, 2025:

Friday, September 27, 2024

Calgary pastor appeals Coutts blockade conviction

Alberta pastor Artur Pawlowski is appealing the 61-day jail sentence he was given for preaching at the 2022 Coutts border blockade. 

'A dangerous precedent': Lawyer for Calgary preacher appeals Coutts protest conviction | CBC News | Meghan Grant:

September 10, 2024 - "The lawyers for a Calgary pastor found guilty of mischief for encouraging protesters to continue blocking the Canada-U.S. border crossing in 2022 say he was communicating with attendees, not inciting them, and should have his conviction overturned. On Tuesday, Artur Pawlowski's appeal was heard by a panel of three Alberta Court of Appeal judges.

"Pawlowski was convicted of inciting mischief based on a videotaped speech he gave on Feb. 3, 2022, at the saloon near the Coutts blockade. Defence lawyer Sarah Miller said her client gave a speech that should be looked at as communicating with protesters but 'did not incite interference with the highway.' 'The glaring absence of any reference to the blockade or the highway is fatal to the Crown's case and is an error in law,' said Miller. 'It would be a dangerous precedent to say you can't express support of protesters.'

"On the day of the speech, protesters had made a deal to leave the border crossing and head to Edmonton. Pawlowski encouraged those protesting COVID-19 health restrictions to stay in Coutts and hold their ground. 'The eyes of the world are fixed right here on you guys. You are the heroes. Don't you dare go breaking the line,' Pawlowski said in the video. The protesters ultimately decided to stay and continue their two week on-again, off-again blockade.

"Miller said the court was not being asked to approve of Pawlowski's speech, rather to consider it in the context of a 'reasonable interpretation of the Criminal Code'.... Miller's co-counsel Evan Best argued that Pawlowski was 'legally justified to give that speech' under the freedom of expression section of the Charter.

"But prosecutor Andrew Barg argued the defence position of legal justification under the free speech section of the Charter 'is wrong.' 'He can give a speech,' said Barg. 'But then there's a point where it crosses a line.' That point was when Pawlowski, in his speech, 'intentionally incites these people to commit a criminal act,' said Barg.

"The trial judge, Justice Gordon Krinke, had found that Pawlowski 'counselled other persons to interfere with the use of Highway 4 in a manner which rendered it useless'....  [Pawlowski was sentenced to 61 days in jail, but was released since he has already spent 51 days locked up in remand - gd]....

"More than a dozen people were charged in connection with the protests and blockade, including four men accused of conspiracy to murder RCMP officers. Those men were not convicted of [that] charge, rather, two pleaded guilty to firearms offences and were released from jail with sentences equal to the time they'd already served. The other two were found guilty of firearms violations and mischief following a trial and were handed 6½-year sentences."

Read more: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/artur-pawlowski-mischief-coutts-blockade-conviction-appeal-1.7319289  

Pastor Artur Pawlowski's lawyer breaks down criminal conviction appeal after impassioned sermon | Rebel News | September 11, 2024:

Sunday, August 4, 2024

Coutts protesters not guilty of murder conspiracy

A jury has acquitted Chris Carbert and Anthony Olienick of conspiracy to murder RCMP officers at the 2022 border blockade in Coutts, Alberta, but convicted them of lesser weapons and mischief charges.

NOT GUILTY! Jury acquits Coutts border blockaders of conspiracy to commit murder | Rebel News | Ezra Levant: 

August 02, 2024 - "Chris Carbert and Tony Olienick had been accused of conspiracy to commit murder against RCMP officers at the 2022 trucker convoy blockade at the Alberta-Montana border crossing in Coutts, Alberta. Both men were denied bail and have spent almost two and a half years in prison awaiting trial.

"Carbert and Olienick were two of the so-called Coutts Four who all faced related charges. The two other men, Chris Lysak and Jerry Morin, accepted a plea bargain from prosecutors, agreeing to plead guilty to minor firearms charges in return for time served.

"The arrest of the Coutts Four was a spectacular and theatrical event, with the RCMP creating a dramatic display of seized firearms, purportedly belonging to the arrested men. Justin Trudeau immediately invoked the Emergencies Act, declaring a form of martial law, citing the Coutts arrests as his pretext. The use of that law was later found to be unconstitutional by [a] Federal Court.

"The Lethbridge jury did find Carbert and Olienick guilty of relatively minor offences, including possession of a firearm for a dangerous purpose and mischief over $5,000. Olienick was also found guilty of possessing an explosive device, which he had argued was for industrial purposes. Given the lengthy time spent in custody, it is unlikely that the men will serve any more time serving a sentence."
Read more: https://www.rebelnews.com/not_guilty_jury_acquits_coutts_border_blockaders_of_conspiracy_to_commit_murder

Coutts defendants found NOT GUILTY of conspiracy to murder, guilty of other charges | Rebel News | August 3, 2024:

The Coutts Trial Verdict: A Silence That Speaks Volumes | The Canadian Muse | Gather 2030, Substack: 

August 03, 2024 - "On August 2, Tony Olienick and Chris Carbert were acquitted of the serious charge of conspiracy to commit murder, but were found guilty of several other charges, including weapons possession and mischief. This verdict, particularly in the context of political dissent and civil liberties, merits a broader conversation.... The silence from major media sources raises important questions about the role of journalism in a democratic society. 

"The Coutts trial highlights significant issues regarding government authority, the right to protest, and the implications of the Emergency Act. These are not merely legal matters; they touch upon the fundamental rights of Canadians and the very fabric of democracy....  They symbolize a moment of reckoning for how dissent is perceived and managed in Canada. 

"The lack of media coverage risks marginalizing these critical discussions, leaving many Canadians unaware of the potential consequences for their own rights and freedoms. In a democracy, silence can be as powerful as speech. The absence of coverage around the Coutts trial serves as a reminder of the responsibility that both the media and citizens share in holding power to account.... 

"The Coutts trial is more than just a legal proceeding; it is a reflection of the ongoing struggle for justice and the protection of civil liberties. As the nation processes the implications of this verdict, the call for a more robust dialogue around these issues is louder than ever. It is time for all voices to be heard, and for the media to play its crucial role in fostering an informed and engaged citizenry."
Read more: https://gather2030.substack.com/p/the-coutts-trial-verdict-a-silence

Thursday, July 18, 2024

"Pipe bombs" used in mining, Coutts trial told

A defense witness has testified that Coutts 4 defendant Anthony Olienick used homemade explosive devices, similar to the two "pipe bombs" police seized when they raided his Claresholm property, in his sandstone mining business.   

'Firecrackers', 'not a big deal': Coutts Trial witness claims alleged pipe bombs were mining tools | Rebel News | Robert Kraychik:

July 17, 2024 - "Brian Lambert, a former business partner of Anthony Olienick's, testified on Monday, July 15 during Olienick's and Chris Carbert's trial in Lethbridge, AB, that he observed his former associate’s use of 'firecrackers' in the context of their joint operations mining sandstone. Lambert’s testimony relates to one charge against Olienick, that he unlawfully possessed an explosive device for a dangerous purpose. 

"The Crown has alleged that two objects found on Olienick's property after his arrest on February 14, 2022, were 'pipe bombs'. Lambert described the 'firecrackers' he said he saw Olienick use years ago as explosives contained within tubes or pipes used for plumbing. He further described them as 'not a big deal' in the context of the world of explosives. He maintained that he would not choose to hold such an explosive in his hands.

"Carbert and Olienick are accused of conspiring to murder police officers during their time at the 2022 Coutts protest and blockade, a peaceful and civilly disobedient demonstration against the decrees, edicts, and orders issued by different levels of government and marketed as “public health” measures to reduce COVID-19 transmission. The two defendants are also charged with unlawful possession of a firearm for a dangerous purpose. Both have pled not guilty to all charges against them.

"Lyndsay Butler, a country music singer, songwriter, and performer ... testified that she brought a guitar in a guitar case with her to the demonstration. The prosecution previously suggested that guitar cases were used to transport firearms for the purposes of executing a conspiracy to murder. Butler was also mentioned in certain text messages sent to and received by the defendants' phones during tbe Coutts protest that the Crown has alleged included coded language related to the alleged conspiracy.... 

"Corrie Turcott, an Albertan who spent 18 days at the Coutts demonstration, ... [testified] that she spent most of her 18 days in Smuggler's Saloon, a small restaurant in the border village that operated as a makeshift meeting center for protesters. She said she spent considerable time in the saloon’s basement, using it as a site to organize and store food and other donated consumables used by the demonstrators.

"The Crown has alleged that the saloon’s basement was used as a site to store a cache of firearms meant for use as part of a conspiracy to murder law enforcement personnel. Turcott testified that she did not observe any firearms in the saloon's basement."

Read more: https://www.rebelnews.com/firecrackers_not_a_big_deal_coutts_trial_witness_claims_alleged_pipe_bombs_were_mining_tools

'Firecrackers', 'not a big deal': Coutts Trial witness claims alleged pipe bombs were mining tools | Rebel News | July 17, 2024:

Wednesday, June 26, 2024

Coutts conspiracy trial, week one

Week 1 of the trial of the Coutts 2  (Tony Olienick and Christ Carbert) on charges of conspiracy to murder police consisted mainly of testimony from three undercover RCMP officers.

Coutts Two Trial Begins With Evidence that is Primarily Hearsay | The Intrepid Viking | Roxanne Halverson, Substack:

June 20, 2024 - "[F]inally, on Thursday June 13, 2024 the trial of the Coutts Two, who had previously been known as the Coutts Four began in earnest.... On trial on charges of conspiracy to commit murder of police (RCMP members) are Tony Olienick and Chris Carbert. They are two Alberta men who were caught in a dragnet of RCMP operations and raids that occurred during the Coutts border blockade protest just outside of the border town of Coutts, Alberta, which was part of the larger Freedom Convoy protest which took place in Ottawa in February of 2022. Protesters were calling for an end to the draconian COVID mandates and restrictions that had been imposed on Canadians by the federal and provincial governments for two long years. 

"Olienick and Carbert were arrested and charged with the conspiracy to murder police along with two other men – Jerry Morin and Chris Lysak. However, this past February, after spending 723 days in custody as they were denied bail, all the original charges against Morin and Lysak were suddenly dropped as they plead[ed] guilty to minor firearms offences.... All four of these men, according to the RCMP, were identified as ‘key’ members of a larger ‘cell’ of bad actors involved in a plot to overthrow the Canadian government. In media briefings the RCMP indicated that there were other ‘unidentified suspects’ of a purported ‘criminal organization’ that the four men allegedly belonged to. Yet, despite assurances by RCMP brass that these ‘unidentified suspects’ would also be rounded up through the intrepid investigative efforts of the RCMP, no such suspects were ever found, or were arrests ever made.... 

"So why, one might ask, has it taken two years to bring the case to trial? After all, under Canada’s justice system, the accused are entitled to a speedy trial. One would think that even a year’s delay in bringing a case to trial would seem unduly long, particularly when said suspects were not granted bail – in the justice system, where under the Trudeau government, bail is even granted to accused cop killers. Yet, now that it’s been two years no one has even batted an eye over this travesty. Not the justice system, not the government and certainly not the media.... 

"The Crown in its opening statements to the jury, which were widely reported in the mainstream media, who now have taken a sudden interest in the case after two years of wilfully ignoring it, were quite dramatic. The Crown prosecutor who gave the opening statement, Matt Dalidowicz told the jury that Olienick and Carbert had, indeed, conspired to kill police officers and believed they were justified in doing so.... According to the Crown, the RCMP faced a 'challenging situation' when the blockade began in January of 2020. He then went on to explain that ... they learned more through their undercover officers (UCO). Those would be three attractive female RCMP members they had assigned to investigate the activities at the Coutts blockade. Dalidowicz told the jury that these UCOs had ... 'discovered a plot to kill police officers, if police enforce the law to end the blockade'.... 

"But there is one fly in the ointment regarding the Crown’s assertions about this ‘plot'. It is predicated on the testimonies and evidence of what these three UCOs ‘uncovered’ and undoubtedly reported to their superiors, one would think. Yet, these police women, who were given this assignment, to investigate, infiltrate and gather evidence on any suspicious activities around the protest, used no wires or recording devices to record the conversations of, or with, any of the protesters. So, it is only their memories and perhaps notes of what they observed or heard that they are relying on.... Strangely enough as the mainstream media were recounting the testimonies of these UCO’s and their ‘conversations’, primarily with Tony Olienick, they didn’t think to mention that none of the evidence they presented could be backed up with recordings of said conversations. The were reporting it as though it did come from wiretaps or recordings, but that has been par for the course on the mainstream media’s laziness in reporting on this case....

"Because these RCMP members continue to operate as UCOs in other operations, their identities had to be protected, therefore they gave their testimonies in a separate courtroom where only the judge, lawyers, the jury, the defendants and the courtroom staff were present. The public and media remained in another courtroom where they could only hear the audio of their testimonies. During their testimonies they were asked whether the RCMP generally used wiretaps and body cameras during undercover operations, to which they replied they usually did. As to why they did not do so in Coutts, their only answer was that did not know, and that someone else would have to answer that question.... 

"The testimonies of the three seemed to focus in on Olienick who seemed to have interacted with them more than the other men. As a matter of fact they all indicated they had little, if any contact with Carbert, which causes one to wonder why he is on trial at all. Many of the things the UCOs testified to in their conversations with Olienick seemed to centre more on how he felt about the police presence there, rather than any particular plot against them. Any such words spoken by Oienick in that regard could also be open to misinterpretation and innuendo as was revealed under cross examination by the defence.

"But coming back to Chris Carbert, who[m] the UCO’s admit they had little if any contact with. Where or how does he fit into the picture? Well, the Crown’s problem is that ... in a ‘conspiracy’ charge, more than one person has to be involved in the plot. When Lysak and Morin were offered and took a plea deal, that left only Carbert and Olienick to keep the ‘conspiracy’ charge alive. So, it would seem that Carbert is being brought along simply to secure such a conviction. But if the evidence against Carbert is so thin, how can a jury possibly convict him? And if they can’t convict him, then how can they convict Olienick, alone, on a conspiracy charge? That seems to be quite a conundrum. How the Crown plans to tackle that conundrum remains to be seen."

Read more: https://roxannehalverson.substack.com/p/coutts-two-trial-begins-with-evidence

On-the-ground: Recap of Day 1 at the Trial of The 4 Coutts Men Accused of Conspiracy to Murder RCMP | Media Bezirgan | July 24, 2023:

 

Wednesday, June 19, 2024

Coutts conspiracy trial gets underway in Alberta

After being held in custody without bail for more than two years, Canada's Coutts 4 – now the Coutts 2, after charges were dropped against two of the alleged conspirators – are finally getting their day in court in Alberta. 

Lawfare Comes to Canada as the Coutts Four Get Their Day in Court | Newsweek | Gord Magill: 

June 18, 2024 - "A trial is currently underway in Canada, and the rights of every Canadian citizen are at stake. Tony Olienick and Chris Carbert are facing farcical charges stemming from their participation in a peaceful protest against Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's COVID-19 response.... Olienick and Carbert are the remaining two of a group of political prisoners arrested in Canada and held without bail since the Freedom Convoy in 2022

"The Freedom Convoy was a populist revolt against Trudeau's authoritarian approach to COVID-19 in the form of a mass act of civil protest led by truck drivers. To combat this peaceful protest, the largest of its kind in Canadian history, Trudeau invoked the Emergencies Act to suspend civil liberties across Canada, freezing bank accounts and laying numerous spurious charges against hundreds of peaceful protesters. Olienick and Carbert were arrested February 13, 2022 in Coutts, Alberta, at a Freedom Convoy protest site the day before Trudeau invoked the Emergencies Act, along with two other men. 

"The group came to be known as the Coutts Four, and they stand accused of some damning charges — conspiracy to murder police officers among them. The charges are completely bogus, yet throughout Canada, early reporting about the men painted them in such a negative light that that many people have presumed them guilty. Their assumed guilt is tied up with Trudeau's larger effort to legitimize the use of the Emergencies Act against peaceful protestors; an inquest into Trudeau's suspension of civil rights surrounding the Freedom Convoy hinges on a conviction in the case of the Coutts Four.... Complicating this effort is the fact that two of the four men were released from prison and had all the original charges against them dropped....

"Olienick and Carbert have been kept in a form of carceral purgatory called 'remand' since being arrested for exercising their once-protected rights to protest. In this purgatory, where they do not have the normal rights afforded convicted felons, they have been denied access to necessary medical care, among other indignities, and Olienick had spent over 90 days in solitary confinement, which is considered torture in most civilized societies.

"Olienick and Carbert's trial finally got underway earlier this month. What little coverage there has been of the trial proceedings has focused on testimony from the undercover officers who were casing the protesters. There is nothing by way of corroborating evidence or recordings of what the accused are alleged to have said, and the Crown's case relies entirely on a negative interpretation of their words based entirely on claims made by the undercover officers.

"The story comes apart under the lightest scrutiny: A group of young female undercover officers were ostensibly sent in to investigate protesters tarred as extremists, who their superior officers suspected of having weapons and an intent to kill them. Yet these officers were sent in with no wires or recording devices of any kind, and no weapons to defend themselves. Does this not raise some pertinent questions? Who authorized this undercover operation? Was it not convenient to make these allegations, given that the day after these men were arrested, the Emergencies Act was invoked? Why has it taken 28 months for such an important case to get under way? Why did two of the co-accused, Jerry Morin and Chris Lysak, have all of the original charges against them dropped?...

"Media coverage of this case has done a great disservice to the Canadian public in not asking these questions. Instead, the media has been cheerleading for a conviction before all the evidence is in by repeating the unsubstantiated claims of the officers and failing to report any countervailing evidence or context crucial to understanding the story....

"If the Canadian government can level ridiculous and baseless charges at people, throw them in jail for over two years while denying them bail for trumped up political reasons, and then have their friends in the media smear the accused, what right to protest does anyone have? What right to free speech, or to any other civil liberties? The trial of these men in Alberta, like the trial of Donald Trump, raises serious questions about our democracy. It is clear that those in our ruling class would rather control the narrative so that you don't ask them."

Read more: https://www.newsweek.com/lawfare-comes-canada-coutts-four-get-their-day-court-opinion-1913946

Witness testimony day 3 at Coutts 2 trial | Thursday, June 13, 24 | Landon Hickok | Bridge City News | June 13, 2024:

Wednesday, February 7, 2024

Two Coutts 4 defendants released after plea deal

Charges of conspiring to murder police officers have been withdrawn against Coutts 4 defendants Chris Lysak and Jerry Morin; the two have pleaded guilty to lesser charges, been sentenced to time served, and released from custody. 

UPDATED: Two Coutts Four members agree to plea deal | Western Standard - Jonathan Bradley: 

February 6, 2024 - "Coutts Four members Chris Lysak and Jerry Morin have accepted a plea deal in their conspiracy to commit murder case. The word from the attendees of the trial is that the conspiracy to commit murder on RCMP charges have been dropped and the two men will be set free,' tweeted Media Bezirgan investigative journalist Mocha Bezirgan on Tuesday. 'I will confirm with the courts once the information related to the plea deal becomes available'.... Bezirgan [also[ said Coutts Four member Anthony Olieneck has a new lawyer, which has delayed his trial until February 20. 

"Bridge City News anchor Hal Roberts acknowledged two of the Coutts Four will be released this afternoon after pleading guilty to a single charge each. [see video] 'Chris Lysak plead[ed] guilty to a restricted weapons charge and Jerry Morin pleaded guilty to conspiracy to traffick a firearm,' said Roberts. 'Chris Carbert and Anthony Olieneck remain held'.... 

"Court of King’s Bench of Alberta Justice David Vaughan Hartigan accepted on Tuesday a joint recommendation by Crown attorneys and defence lawyers Greg Dunn and Daniel Song for Morin and Lysak to be handed the equivalent of sentences of time in custody. 

"That amounted to a three-and-a-half year sentence for Morin and three years for Lysak. It is normal for accused people in remand to get one-and-a-half days credit for every day served. Morin was given enhanced credit for spending periods of time in solitary confinement.

"Dunn indicated he could not comment at length on the verdict for Morin because of the ongoing litigation against Carbert and Olieneck. 'Mr. Morin has steadfastly maintained from the very beginning that he played no part of any alleged conspiracy to murder police officers and is relieved and grateful that those charges and associated allegations have been withdrawn by the Crown,' said Dunn. 'Moreover, the charge that Mr. Morin plead guilty to does not suggest that Mr. Morin at any time took firearms into Coutts — only that he agreed to'.... 

"Song said Lysak was satisfied with the outcome. 'To be clear, Mr. Lysak did not admit to possessing his handgun for a dangerous purpose,' said Song. 'He did not attend the Coutts protests with the intent to harm anyone'.... 

"The RCMP laid charges against 13 Albertans in 2022 after an investigation that resulted in it seizing a cache of weapons during the Coutts Border Blockade. Lysak, Morin, Olienick, and Lethbridge, AB, resident Chris Carbert, 44, were slapped with conspiracy to commit murder, possession of a weapon for dangerous purposes and mischief over $5,000 charges. Lysak faced an additional charge of uttering threats.

"Magrath, AB, resident Ursula Allred, 22; Red Deer, AB, resident Luke Berk, 62; Raymond, AB, residents Evan Colenutt, 23, Justin Martin, 22, Stewart Eastin Oler, 22, and Janx Zaremba, 18; Calgary resident Johnson Chickow Law, 39; Coutts resident Joanne Person, 62, and undisclosed Alberta location resident Jaclyne Martin, 39, have all been charged with possession of a weapon and mischief to property over $5,000.

"Carbert was denied bail on January 15, despite being held in remand for 702 days for charges connected to the Coutts Border Blockade.... A publication ban remains in place, denying the public some details on the trial."

Read more: https://www.westernstandard.news/alberta/breaking-two-coutts-four-members-agree-to-plea-deal/52185

February 06, 2024 | Full Newscast | Bridge City News (story runs first 2-1/2 minutes): 

Tuesday, January 16, 2024

Bail denied for Coutts 4 defendant Chris Carbert

Bail denied for Chris Carbert, member of Coutts Four | Western Standard | Lee Harding: 


Chris Carbert. Courtesy Facebook.

January 15, 2024 - "Bail has been denied for Chris Carbert, one of four men held in remand for 702 days for charges connected with a demonstration at the US border crossing at Coutts, AB in February 2022. 

"Carbert is accused of plotting to kill RCMP officers. He is charged with conspiracy to murder, possession of a weapon and mischief. A publication ban remains in place.... 

"However, the verdict was reported on social media. Independent journalist Mocha Bezirgan reported on Twitter ("X") that temperatures of -50C with wind chill left the courtroom only half full of attendees. He said two rows normally reserved for media no longer were there due to lack of interest at previous meetings. By 10:58 a.m. he could report that bail had been denied.

"'This isn’t justice!' a protester yelled at the end of the sentencing. Sheriffs removed him [from] the court room.

"In a post to Twitter ("X"), Independent journalist Jason Lavine said he was not surprised.

"'I did speak with Chris last week on why I thought this would be the outcome. After his bail hearing, I didn't think the Judge would take the risk to the public safety with release when the trial was a few months away' ... tweeted Lavine. 'Unfortunately, Chris and the other men are charged with some of the worst charges in Alberta's history. I couldn't see the Judge ruling against this initiative. I am heartbroken for Chris and his family. This does expose significant problems with the "justice" system.'"

Read more: https://www.westernstandard.news/alberta/bail-denied-for-chris-carbert-member-of-coutts-four/51673

Sunday, October 8, 2023

Why are the Coutts 4 still in jail?

Why are the Coutts 4 still in jail, with no bail and no trial date, more than 18 months after their arrest? A former Freedom Convoy participant suspects the worst.

Justin Trudeau's Political Prisoners | Newsweek | Gord Magill: 

July 13, 2023 - "It's been 18 months since Canada's Freedom Convoy rocked the world, when truckers from all corners of Canada descended on Ottawa to protest Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's vindictive and punishing vaccine mandates. The ... shockwaves were felt throughout the world—both from the power of the protest and the vicious response to it by Trudeau. While the Convoy was still hundreds of kilometers from Ottawa, Trudeau's Public Safety Minister, Marco Mendocino, was planning a media campaign deploying 'a similar message to the one used in response to the Jan. 6 attacks in Washington, D.C.' which would emphasize the 'more extreme elements' of the protestors. Trudeau memed himself into believing that a January 6 type insurrection was about to storm Parliament Hill, and promptly vacated the city to hide at a chalet in rural Quebec, where he remained for several days.... 

"Trudeau invoked The Emergencies Act, which allows the Canadian government to suspend civil liberties in the face of a so-called state of emergency. The invocation brought an end to the protests and launched a Kafkaesque nightmare for many who were involved. Bank accounts were seized and funds confiscated. Tamara Lich was arrested, and still faces charges of 'counseling mischief' for her role organizing the protest. And four others — Chris Lysak, Chris Carbert, Anthony (Tony) Olienick, and Jerry Morin — have been held without a trial and without bail for charges related to 'conspiracy to commit murder' against Canadian police officers at the Coutts, Alberta border crossing.

"These are serious charges, which should imply serious evidence presented at an expeditious trial; yet at time of writing, it has been 515 days since these men were arrested, and no trial has yet taken place. Worse, the evidence on offer is vague and ambiguous: text messages, testimony from two undercover RCMP officers working the crowd at the Coutts protest site, and a widely circulated photo of allegedly confiscated weapons that provided the main justification for the invocation of The Emergencies Act.

"Whatever the charges against them, the denial of bail is an egregious departure from the norm, and has been given no explanation. As Donald Best, a former detective and 15 year veteran of the Toronto Police Services, pointed out, everybody gets bail in Canada, including a suspect accused of the first degree murder of a Toronto Police Officer.... Yet there's no bail set for the Coutts Four, whose ... actual trial date will be set for some time in 2024. These are political prisoners, pure and simple. They are being denied basic rights due to even the most violent of criminals because they are on the wrong side of the Trudeau government. They are being used as a fig leaf, the last shred of Trudeau's legitimacy for invoking The Emergencies Act and for the massive overreach of freezing bank accounts and seizing assets that it incurred.

"It seems that Trudeau is determined not only to smear the Convoy as a Jan. 6 Canadian redo, but to treat the Coutts Four in a similar way, depriving them of their civil rights as the United States did to many protesters arrested in the days and weeks following that fateful day in D.C. Hundreds spent over a year in Guantanamo Bay-like conditions in D.C. prisons, denied bail and treated worse than convicted rapists and serial killers.... But few in Canada are willing to expose our version of these abuses.

"Margaret 'Granny' Mackay of Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta is one of them. Mackay is the creator and administrator of the Alberta Political Prisoners Facebook page and is in regular contact with the accused and their legal team. Mackay has highlighted the subpar treatment the men have received in remand, including being held in segregation, a polite term for the torture known as solitary confinement; having necessary medical treatment delayed; being denied supplements for treating specific health issues; and being granted extremely limited visitation time from family.

"Did they commit crimes worthy of such treatment? We just don't know. As Mackay has maintained through all of this, 'I'm after the truth. The truth is locked in a remand center right now, and it's not being allowed out'....  Jason Lavigne, an independent journalist in western Alberta, put it [that] "There is an inverted house of cards Trudeau, Mendocino, Rouleau, all of these people have built, and at the bottom are the Coutts 4.' If these men are exonerated, Canadians will start demanding answers about a whole lot of other things....

"The Coutts Four are the last of Trudeau's political enemies whom he can punish with impunity; they have no power and the full weight of the state against them. If his government can allow murderers and terrorists out on bail, they should extend the same to the men from Coutts and get on with the trial.... We don't yet know if these men are innocent or guilty of the charges against them, but it flies in the face of justice that they have not yet faced trial and have been denied bail."

Read more: https://www.newsweek.com/justin-trudeaus-political-prisoners-opinion-1812866

Fort Macleod Councillor speaks on the plight of the Coutts 4 | Marco Van Huigenbos, Guest | Bridge City News | June 30, 2023:

Friday, November 11, 2022

Emergencies Act no help in clearing AB blockade

Alberta received no federal help to deal with protest blockade last winter: inquiry | CityNews Ottawa - Laura Osman & Marie-Danielle Smith, Canadian Press:

November 10, 2022 -"Senior civil servants from Alberta and Ontario left the impression at a public inquiry Thursday that Ottawa was not keen to come to their aid to deal with protest blockades last winter.... Neither of the bureaucrats from those provinces felt the use of the [Emergencies Act] was necessary, and in Alberta, the inquiry heard, the legislation wasn't useful at all.... The public inquiry is tasked with determining whether the federal government was justified in triggering the legislation for the first time since it became law in 1988.

"A convoy of 1,000 vehicles of all types drove to Coutts, Alta., on Jan. 29 to protest provincial and federal COVID-19 health restrictions, blocking the highway in both directions and halting the movement of trade. The Liberal government invoked the Emergencies Act on Feb. 14, the same day RCMP in Alberta moved in to arrest protesters in Coutts. The prime minister ... Justin Trudeau held a consultation with premiers before invoking the act, and notes taken by political staffers and submitted to the public inquiry detail their comments and concerns. Handwritten notes taken by aides in the Prime Minister's Office and Saskatchewan government say former Alberta premier Jason Kenney worried that triggering the emergency legislation would be a 'very serious provocation' and a 'net negative'.... 

"Marlin Degrand, the assistant deputy minister in the Alberta solicitor general's office, told the commission earlier Thursday that RCMP had the power to clear the convoy from the border, but it didn't have the co-operation it needed to get the job done.... Alberta looked all over the province, in British Columbia and Saskatchewan and even the United States, but tow companies refused to help.... The province opted against declaring a state of emergency to try and force tow operators to help, and instead asked for federal help in a formal letter on Feb. 5.

"The Liberal government never officially responded to that request, but did draft a letter to turn Alberta down on Feb. 12, the commission learned. The undelivered letter said the province had all the legal authority it needed to deal with the protest. Degrand said he would agree that Alberta didn't need any more legal authority; what it lacked were the tow trucks....

"On Feb. 21, [federal Emergency Preparedness Minister Bill] Blair texted [Alberta Municipal Affairs Minister Rick] McIver to tell him that the Emergencies Act was effective at addressing the tow truck issue. 'You were too late and did the wrong thing,' McIver responded, telling the minister that by the time the state of emergency was invoked the Coutts blockade was already over."

Read more: https://ottawa.citynews.ca/national-news/alberta-received-no-federal-help-to-deal-with-protest-blockade-last-winter-inquiry-6083771

Monday, September 26, 2022

Coutts Alberta residents question police narrative

On Feb. 14, 2022, the RCMP arrested 14 Freedom Convoy protesters in Coutts, AB, charging 4 with conspiracy to murder police - which the Trudeau government used to justify invoking the Emergencies Act that day. But some who know the men aren't buying the official narrative.

‘Somebody Planted the Guns’: In Canada, a Raided, Distrusting Village Blames the Police | New York Times - Catherine Porter:

September 24, 2022 - ""So pervasive is the belief here that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is a dictator-in-the-making that ... many residents of the village, Coutts, Alberta, think the biggest event that occurred here in recent memory — when the police raided a local home in February and revealed a frightening cache of weapons — was a hoax perpetrated by the police to silence an antigovernment protest.... 'It may have been a conspiracy,' said Bill Emerson, who for four decades has lived across the street from the home the police raided....

"The police raid came during the time of Canada’s Freedom Convoy, which began as a movement by truckers to challenge a government vaccination mandate but spread to include a wide array of antigovernment grievances. The stark contrast between the mainstream account of what happened — the police disarming a small group of protesters with violent intentions — and the conspiracy-fueled one — a government attempt to demonize the protesters — reflects a burgeoning polarization of Canadian society....

"The Freedom Convoy movement — that aimed at one point to replace the federal government with a ruling committee including protesters, [not true - gd] and which Mr. Trudeau dismissed as a 'fringe minority' with 'unacceptable views' — is hardly a fringe. Months later, it garners the support of one in four Canadians, according to a recent poll, and some of its beliefs have entered mainstream politics. 'We have crossed a Rubicon, and there ain’t no going back,' said Evan Balgord, executive director of the Canadian Anti-Hate Network. 'Canada hasn’t faced something like this, especially not in a long time. How do we deal with a movement that wants to dismantle democracy?'

Coutts, Alberta (upper) and Sweet Grass, Montana. Aerial photo by Joe Mabel, 2013. CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

"Coutts is a small border village 185 miles southeast of Calgary.... Before last winter, the village’s faint claim to fame was a mention by President Obama of its baseball fields, which nose right up against the international border.... Then, one frigid day last winter, hundreds of tractor-trailers and trucks rumbled down the highway to the village’s edge and stopped, blocking all lanes leading to the normally busy border crossing. They were a splinter group of the Freedom Convoy.... In Coutts, the village’s only bar, shuttered by the pandemic [restrictions - gd], was reopened to be their headquarters.

"All the while, scores of provincial police, members of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, kept watch. Over 17 days, 552 officers were assigned to the village of just 224, according to the mayor. On the fourteenth evening of protest, when a local church was holding a Sunday service in the bar, the police arrived in full military gear, wielding automatic weapons, and arrested two men in the crowd. Later that night, they executed a search warrant on a house, where a local woman was hosting many protesters. Over a few hours, the police arrested 14 people. Most were charged with mischief over 5,000 Canadian dollars, or about $3,700, and possession of a weapon for a dangerous purpose. But four men face a far more serious charge — conspiracy to commit murder, which carries a potential life-in-prison sentence.

"Undercover officers witnessed the set up of what they believed to be a delivery of guns to Coutts, search warrants reveal.... A photo of the cache of weapons [police] seized included rifles, handguns, high capacity magazines, ammunition and bullet proof vests. All four of the men charged with conspiracy to commit murder are middle-aged, blue collar workers from Southern Alberta. A day before the police raid, one of them, Jerry Morin, recorded a video on Facebook, calling his friends to Coutts to help 'hold the line.' 'There’s no excuses,' said Mr. Morin, a 40-year-old who installs and repairs electrical lines. 'This is war'....

"The day of the raid, [the Trudeau] government passed a sweeping emergency bill, granting police wide powers to arrest protesters, and instructing banks to freeze accounts linked to the convoy. Federal Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino pointed to Coutts as part of the justification.... 

"Marco Van Huigenbos, the main leader of the Coutts protest, is so convinced that at least two of the four men are not guilty, he is subsidizing their families with 10,000 Canadian dollars a month. The money is from leftover funds raised in Coutts.... 'They are using these guys to send a message,' said Mr. Huigenbos, a town councilor and business owner from nearby Fort Macleod, who himself was recently charged with mischief over 5,000 Canadian dollars. 'There is political influence here.'"

Read more: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/24/world/canada/freedom-convoy-coutts-alberta.html