Monday, May 25, 2015

Scaremongering about PATRIOT Act sunset

Scaremongering about the Patriot Act Sunset | Just Security: Jameel Jaffer, American Civil Liberties Union:

May 24, 2015 - "In a last-ditch effort to scare lawmakers into preserving unpopular and much-abused surveillance authorities, the Senate Republican leadership and some intelligence officials are warning that allowing Section 215 of the Patriot Act to sunset would compromise national security.  (One particularly crass example from Senator Lindsey Graham: “Anyone who neuters this program is going to be partially responsible for the next attack.”)  Some media organizations have published these warnings without challenging them, which is unfortunate.  The claim that the expiration of Section 215 would deprive the government of necessary investigative tools or compromise national security is entirely without support.

"First, there’s no evidence that the call-records program is effective in any meaningful sense of the word.   The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board, which reviewed classified files, 'could not identify a single instance involving a threat to the United States in which the telephone records program made a concrete difference in the outcome of a counterterrorism investigation.'  The President’s Review Group ... determined that the call-records program had 'not [been] essential to preventing attacks,' and that, to the extent the program had contributed to terrorism investigations, the records in question 'could readily have been obtained in a timely manner' using targeted demands.

"Second, there’s no evidence that other forms of collection under Section 215 have been any more effective.... [A] report by the Inspector General released this past week states that FBI personnel were 'unable to identify any major case developments that resulted from use of the records obtained through use of Section 215 orders'...

"Third, the sunset of Section 215 wouldn’t affect the government’s ability to conduct targeted investigations of terrorist threats.... It can use administrative subpoenas or grand jury subpoenas.  It can use pen registers. It can use national security letters. It can use orders served under the Electronic Communications Privacy Act.  If Section 215 sunsets, it can use the provision that Section 215 amended, which will allow it to collect business records of hotels, motels, car and truck rental agencies, and storage rental facilities.

"The sunset of Section 215 would undoubtedly be a significant political loss for the intelligence community ... but there’s no support for the argument that the sunset of Section 215 would compromise national security."

Read more:
'via Blog this'

No comments:

Post a Comment